Brown County’s Economic Engine?

economic engine

What is Brown “County’s” Economic Engine?
Spoiler Alert: It is NOT tourism.
Updated May 25, 2022

May 20, 2022. Nashville can’t rely on its tourism industry to fund infrastructure needs  by Joe Hren

Brown County Matters – Facebook Post Discussion

For Brown County, the overall beauty of the landscape and terrain is what has attracted residents, artists, and visitors.  Brown County is the most forested county in the State. The landscape also attracted the artists and led to the State creating the State Park.  Tourism emerged to serve the visitors.  Outdoor Recreation (OR) and an appreciation of the landscape – especially in the Fall, have been main attractors.

The MAIN REVENUE GENERATION “engine” for the county is RESIDENTS! The majority include individuals that live here and commute outside the county (or can work from home) for the better paying jobs, residents in occupations other than tourism, and retirees.

  • The Brown County Community Readiness Initiative, a survey and economic assessment conducted by the Ball State Economic and Research Institute, concluded that Brown County’s greatest potential for economic growth is not tourism, but as a bedroom community. – BC Democrat – Sara Clifford
  • The expansion of broadband within the county is a new and positive change. It supports the live her, work elsewhere philosophy.
  • The Regional Opportunity Initiative (ROI) in which Brown County is a member, have identifed that there are more good jobs in the region than individuals to fill them.

In 2019, 7,126 residents reported adjusted gross (taxable) income of $425 million dollars. This is the source of the revenue for the county government.  The county is primarily funded by income and property taxes.

A study in 2017 by Rockport Analytics identified that tourism accounted for 636 jobs and $12.2 million in wages and proprietor income.

An updated 2020 Rockport Analytic Study shows $12.1 million in wages.

Increases in Nashville’s assessed property values are the lowest in the county which means other residents are paying higher taxes to help fund the cost of government and infrastructure.

Government data indicates service level jobs are among the lowest paid. The Rockport Analytics study identifed “an average wage of $19,259 in gross wages.

The State is primarily funded by Sales Tax and Income Tax.  Increasing revenue from sales tax is the driver for subsiding the marketing of tourism via the innkeepers tax.

Revenue from the innkeeprs tax is a county assest. Review and approval of how this money is spent is the statutory responsiblity of the County Council.  The revenue from this tax can be spent on just about anything that leads to attracting tourists.

    • Examples:  A “music venue”, tourist center, historical preservation, wellness, agriculture, education,  recreation, etc.  Additional examples on types, categories and tourism related issues provided at Tourism-Wikipedia.  See also overtourism and too much tourism.
    • The Convention Visitors Commission (CVC) is responsible for developing a plan and budget and the Conventions Vistors Bureau (CVB) is provided funing to market tourism. Before the Music Center (which now uses the revenue for mortgage and operating expenses),  the CVB was given approximately 95% of the innkpeers tax revenue.  Results from the marketing strategies have not been made publically available.
    • The Commissioners are responsble for developing a County Comprehensive Plan that should include a vision for tourism.  The current plan does not include this vision.  Consequently, residents not involved in the tourims industry have no input on how and where the revenue from the innkeerps tax will be spent.  However, this can be easily changed by electing more resident focused representatives.

Brown County Music Center (BCMC).  The Project was led by innkeepers that benefirectlyitted indrectly from the support of county government and investment of tax dollars (more heads in bed) with no risk. Elected officials fast-tracked the process and refused to hold any public  meetings with the exception of the meeting needed to approve the project.

    • GUEST OPINION: Time will tell what music center’s impact will be, by Tim Clark. The stated aim for this project was to promote and support tourism and the tourism industry primarily in Nashville. In fact, it was stated at a June 2017 presentation at the Playhouse that when using the revenue from the innkeepers tax to finance a tourism-related project, the investment had to result in overnight stays, i.e., “ heads in beds.” This was not a true statement, and to my knowledge, was never retracted publicly. Revenue from the innkeepers tax can be used for any project that promotes tourism.

    • BCMC: Brown County Music Center (Maple Leaf): For the Record. History of the project.

County Economic Development Strategic Plan

    • Econ Development Strategic Plan and Timeline – The Plan was “accepted” for payment by the commissioners but not approved by the commissioners nor reviewed or approved at a formal meeting of the Redevelopment Commission (RDC). In addition, the public did not have the opportunity  to comment.
    • Dec 3, 2019. Brown County Democrat.  New county economic plan released By Sara Clifford
    • The entire 79-page plan first became public after a Nov. 20 public hearing with the Brown County Commissioners and Brown County Redevelopment Commission. However, neither group had read the entire plan by the time of the hearing, and the public hadn’t had an opportunity to see it yet.

County Economics

  • An income survey commissioneed by the County RDC identifed that 53.1% of county residents are in the low to moderate income level.  This qualified the county for federal planning grants. Approximately over 50% of students in the schools qualify for free or reduced lunches.
  • Income Trends 1999-2018. Trends on those reporting income of $50,000 or more are trending up. Trends on those making $30,000 and less trending down.

Trends in Tourism.

  • Nashville has identified its intent to be a “driver” of regional tourism.
  • From seasonal to year round.  Hard Truth Hills and The Brown County Music Center attract more year-round tourism. They also attract additional tourism ventures such as tourist home rentals, the planned resort at Rawhide Ranch and a new tiny house campground.
  • The Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) voted against a 185 Site RV Campground.  Views expressed support for the project but not the location.
  • Despitre the increase in the number of tourists, state highways (46 and 135) and county roads will likely remain at two-lanes for the foreseeable future.
  • Another change is in the increase in the number of liquor licenses.
  • Mountain-Biking another new attraction.
  • Nov 19, 2021 — Out-Door Music — Nashville Town Council working on changes to the Noise Ordinance.  Nashville Noise Ordinance – For  the Record
    • DRAFT – Town Noise Ordinance  .”..It shall be unlawful under this ordinance to: “Intentionally create sound/noise louder than 90 decibels between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. Sunday through Thursday or between 11:00 p.m. and 7 a.m. on Friday or Saturday.”
    • Brown County Matters – Facebook Post

Nashville – Development and Tax Strategy

  • Nashville includes most if not all of its territory in a Tax Increment Financing (TIF) District. This means that the town (not the county) retain the increased property tax revenue as a result of  development.
  • Nashville has also identifed their desire to expand sewer service to areas outside the town limits without identifying a need. Expansion may help to spread the cost and maintance to more customers.
  • Nashvilles Strategic Advisor on the proposed Little Opry Apartment Complex: “And so to get sanitary sewer there and get people off septic, obviously is an EPA mandate. I’d love to see that.”
    • Brown County Democrat: GUEST OPINION: More evidence needed that sewers necessary, By Tim Clark
    • Unnecessary infrastructure costs (sewers for example) add to the cost of living. The Helmsburg rate of $92.50 is outrageous. And many residents may need help with reparing and replacing septic systems.

Challenges 

  • Brown County has one of the highest median home prices in the state. This reinforces the fact that there is still a demand for people to live her but generate income from outside the county.
  • The lack of “Affordable Housing” has been a recurring topic that market forces (supply/demand) have not resolved. The tourism industry may be especially effected by attracting workers at modest pay scales that can not afford to live in the county.
  • ROI Housing Study – Brown County’s section starts on page 43.
  • Avoid Gentrification?  Policies that lead to increases in the cost of living (taxes, utilities, housing) where the lower income residents are replaced with those with incomes in the middle to higher income levels.

Schools – Steady Decline in Enrollments 2008-2022 (Democrat, Nov 17, 2021 Board OKs budget for next year as enrollment declines

BC School Enrollment 2008 - 2022

  • Causes of the decline? State code changed in the 2008/09 period that allowed residents to send their kids to any public school without cost. Residents that commuted to jobs outside the county could choose schools in the surrounding counties. Home Schooling options also made it more attractive for parents to support this option. On demographics, we have one of the oldest median ages in the state. Low enrollment is also due to lower birth rates. And, high median home prices and lack of an inventory of homes in the starter (affordable) range may also be contributing to the decline. Most residents have always chosen to live here but commute outside the county for the better-paying jobs. Differences now may be the pay of jobs, and more competition for housing in the county which drives up prices.

Tax Policy

  • Given the tax base, the commissioners and council chose to rely on increases in income tax and keep property taxes low.  The income rate became one of the highest in the state and was doubled in 10 years, and maxed out. The county recently shifted policy from income to property.
  • Property tax rates have been among the lowest in the state.  This makes owning property, tourist rentals, and second homes more attractive. This also contribites to higher median home values.
  • 2021 Indiana Income Tax Rates by County page 3. Brown County rate: 025234 or2.5234%.  The max limit set by the state is 2.5% but they allow a cost-of living increase. The highest rate in the statye is Pulaski county at .032475*

Additional Information

  • Andy Rogers: Vision for Brown County and Nashville

    • “People say, ‘Well, we can’t change.’ But we can change and still retain some of the flavor of Brown County. We need people to live here. I’m in the tourist business but we don’t want to turn this town over to the tourists. You can go to Gatlinburg if you want to see what happens to a town that turns it all over to business. It’s not a town anymore—it’s a shopping center. We need people here. This town needs to be alive.”
    • “We don’t need to be slick and highly commercial. We need to be more country. Country is what we sell…. We need to maintain that. Once you destroy that, it won’t come back.” 
  • A study of tourism and economic sustainability by Tim Clark.  Provides context regarding tourism-related jobs and wages. Note: The proponents of the government-owned Music Center project claimed that the Music Center “….  could be what it takes to turn things around economically for Brown County.”  This article was written to offer another perspective.  The county is funded primarily by income and property tax.  

The Deming Dimension

Deming Dimension 12 days

Deming’s contributions in the area of quality improvement were recognized by Fortune magazine as being among the 20 that have shaped the modern world of business and by U.S. News and World Report as one of nine turning points in history.

The top turning point was identified as “The Apostle Paul, whose preaching and eloquent writings led to mass acceptance of Christianity. 

SPC Press is pleased to offer, as a free download, the internationally acclaimed self-study course 12 Days to DemingWritten by our colleague and friend, Dr. Henry Neave, this class is without a doubt the best self-study curriculum available today on the thoughts and teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Those who might be interested in this course should read the Preface and Welcome in the file “A. PLEASE START HERE” to discover why Dr. Neave refers to this as an active-learning course.

This is an excellent supplement and follow-on to what Deming presented in his Four-Day Seminars. I had the opportunity to attend one these in 1988.

Henry Neave was a friend, student, and colleague of Dr. Deming. Deming wrote the forward to Neave’s book – The Deming Dimension.  In this book, Deming provides the secret on page 57 to understand the foundation of his theory, principles, and method. He stated the following:

If I had to reduce my message for management to just a few words, 
I’d say it all has to do with reducing variation.” WED

This conclusion is the equivalent of living at a time in history where it was an accepted belief that the world was flat.  It takes some time to overcome the old belief and adopt the new. To help shorten the learning curve, check out my site at Success Through Quality.

Excerpts from a LinkedIn Discussion on supporting improvements at the national level. It started with Congress wanting to spend trillions on an infrastructure project:

  • Does anyone know what the process is for tracking outcomes and ensuring the money is spent as intended? Does this include frequent reporting on status? Any examples from past spending bills? Any reports that the money spent was wasted? How has the overall process for accountability improved over time?
  • Our system was designed to support continuous improvement. The flaw in the system is the lack of a shared method. It would also help if “We The People” acknowledged that we are “top management.” You can delegate accountability to elected officials but not responsibility.
  • A study referenced at Represent.US – The Problem identifies results from a study that indicated that data from nearly 2000 public opinion surveys that compared what the public (top management) wanted to what the government actually did, concluded that the opinions of 90% of Americans (top management) have essentially no impact at all.  This finding was not challenged by the legacy media but led to whether America was functioning as an oligarchy.Elected officials should be serving as our “lobbyists” in supporting legislation that leads to outcomes where we all benefit, or at least are not any worse off in the long term. But, this is probably not enough – citizens need to become educated and engaged. And, we need a “method” that will be used to determine when change (new laws, policies, regulations) leads to improvement.
  • Deming identified that you just needed a critical mass of leaders to support the needed changes. This includes a relatively small percentage of individuals within groups, communities, organizations, industries, and countries.  These leaders would need to have a basic understanding of variation, including common and special causes of variation, tampering, stable and unstable systems in the context of the PDSA cycle. This should be supported using common language and terms and avoiding the quality jargon. The aim is to support changes that lead to results where everyone can benefit, or at least, are not any worse off in the long-term. The basics can be successfully taught and applied at the middle school level.  The challenges are from those that support suboptimal (zero-sum) outcomes, want to remain in their comfort zones, and/or support and have a vested interest in the status quo.  These types of challenges have always required leadership to help overcome.  What’s NEW is the Deming-based methods. Anyone that has made and sustained a change has applied the new methods using different terms. A shared method and framework can produce significant and immediate improvement at any level.
  • … “hidden truths.” It’s a given – every man-made system has a level of corruption. The degree of corruption correlates to the level of transparency. And depending on the moral standard used, “truth” can be relative.

Additional Information

Data Sanity (Part 1 of 5): “Which of Dr. Deming’s 14 Points should I start with?”​ Answer: “NONE of them!”​ (and ALL of them)

Current Times, End-Times, Better Times – A Way Ahead

American-Flag-Distress-signal_rt1

Current Times, End Times, Better Times – A Way Ahead
Updated: Jan 11, 2023 (added the speech from – Oct 2023 Freedom Festival)
By Tim J. Clark

Oct 14, 2023Freedom Fest – Video / Speeches

    • 0:00 Pledge and Anthem
    • 6:33 Micah Beckwith – Paster of Life Church in Noblesville IN, currently campaigning for Lt. Governor of Indiana
    • 22:56 John Jacob – former State Representative for District 93, (Perry Township and a portion of Franklin Township in Marion County)
    • 49:03 Tim J. Clark – Commentator and Brown County Political Watchdog
    • 1:07:51 Pastor Jon Schrock – Senior Representative of the John Birch Society
    • 1:39:23 Curtis Hill – former IN Attorney General, currently campaigning for Governor of Indiana.

Dec 13, 2022Living in “Sudden Death Overtime” According to new surveys, Americans believe the end times by Mark Hitchcock.  PDF  Copy:  Living in _Sudden Death Overtime_ – by Mark Hitchcock

    • “The Pew Research survey pointed to recent events that may contribute to the growing sense that the end is near: …..
    • So, to summarize, this means that 10 percent of all Americans believe Jesus will definitely or probably return in their lifetime, 55 percent believe He will return someday, and 39 percent believe we are living in the end times—and that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is a specific sign.”
    • ...these findings reveal that belief about the end times and biblical prophecy is much stronger and more pervasive than we might have suspected. This should stir each of us to be even more committed to understand our times in light of biblical prophecy and live with a sense of urgency, expectation, and faithful proclamation.

Brown County Indiana – Freedom Rally

My Speech – audio (20 minutes) – Oct 15, 2022 Freedom Rally

My speech (script) – Freedom Rally, Brown County Indiana, Nov 21, 2021. 2021_11_21_2 FINAL Speech Freedom Rally. Speech included references to the assessments provided by Archbishop Vigano.

Update to the Letter – Flag Officers 4 America “A Republic If You Can Keep It” Open Letter from Retired Generals and Admirals October 17, 2022

    • “Our Nation is in deep peril. We are in a fight for our survival as a Constitutional Republic like no other time since our founding in 1776. The conflict is between supporters of Socialism and Marxism vs. supporters of Constitutional freedom and liberty.” – Open Letter from Retired Generals and Admirals (May 2021)
    • June 30, 2022. Interview. Archbishop Vigano joined Steve Bannon on the War Room this morning.  The Archbishop has been a spiritual leader against the New World Order over the past few years as he understands what’s going on and has the courage to share it.

      • A “silent coup” is a coup d’état that takes place without the use of force, carried out by a government that exercises power in an unconstitutional way.  In this case the coup was carried out in all the Western nations almost simultaneously …  

      • The eventual return of Donald Trump to the White House would allow for real peace negotiations, once the deep state has been eradicated from the Administration and government agencies.  …. In any case, the mid-term elections could allow the Republicans to have a majority in the House and in the Senate, once the servants of the deep state – including first of all the “neo-cons” – have been ousted. … The failure of the effort to blame Trump for the farce of the assault on the Capitol ought to dissuade its organizers – among whom we cannot fail to number Nancy Pelosi – from trying to replicate the scene next fall, which would fall into the grotesque, in addition to being a case of déjà vu.
      • The world can and must return to God: …  Praise the Lord, all you nations, praise him all you peoples. Quoniam confirmata est super nos misericordia ejus; et veritas Domini manet in æternum (Ps 116:2) – For his Mercy is confirmed upon us, and the Truth of the Lord remains forever.

July 5, 2022. The Great Regression: All hail our globalist overlords by “… there are plenty of linguistic reasons alone to be suspicious of the grandiose notion of a top-down, international, and fundamental transformation of the way the world is supposed to work…

Context for the Speech

“Republics decline into democracies and democracies
degenerate into despotisms.” – Aristotle

Union Down U.S. Flag. According to the U.S. Flag Code, “The flag should never be displayed with the union down, except as a signal of dire distress in instances of extreme danger to life or property.” This post introduces the case that the U.S. is in “extreme danger to life and property.”

U.S. Flag and a Way Ahead for Brown County and America. An assessment of the state of America provided in a 2021 Open Letter from over 122 Retired Generals and Admirals: concluded that: “Our Nation is in deep peril. We are in a fight for our survival as a Constitutional Republic like no other time since our founding in 1776. The conflict is between supporters of Socialism and Marxism vs. supporters of Constitutional freedom and liberty.”

NY Times – Revise U.S History and Get a New Flag?

Gradually then Suddenly. “How did you go bankrupt?” Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly.” ― Ernest Hemingway, The Sun Also Rises

    • “I do not say that democracy has been more pernicious on the whole, and in the long run, than monarchy or aristocracy. Democracy has never been and never can be so durable as aristocracy or monarchy; but while it lasts, it is more bloody than either. Remember, democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself. There never was a democracy yet that did not commit suicide. It is in vain to say that democracy is less vain, less proud, less selfish, less ambitious, or less avaricious than aristocracy or monarchy. It is not true, in fact, and nowhere appears in history. Those passions are the same in all men, under all forms of simple government, and when unchecked, produce the same effects of fraud, violence, and cruelty.” – John Adams
    • As we rush towards our World War 3 rendezvous with destiny, aided and abetted by politicians placed in power by globalist billionaires hellbent on the destruction of our way of life, so they own everything and you own nothing, I can’t help but ponder who is to blame and could we have avoided this dystopian outcome.
    • They hold all the cards. They control the governments, corporations, banks, legacy media, social media, entertainment industries, military industrial complex, sickcare Big Pharma complex, and the mental processes of the masses through their mind control/propaganda technology. Their hubris and arrogance have reached peak altitude and exuberance. They believe they are invincible. That will be their fatal weakness.
    • I don’t believe their propaganda machine will be able to convince the masses this was the fault of Trump or right wing conspiracists. Their pain and suffering are due to Federal Reserve bankers, corrupt politicians of the uni-party, and the media who has lied to them non-stop for the last decade. Woke is going to mean something different in the near future.
    • The only option is to organize in local communities of like-minded people to try and survive the coming storm. Get out of cities. Prep as much as you are able, with enough food, water, and fuel to sustain your family for an extended period of time. Stock up on guns, ammo, cash, gold, silver, and barterable items. On whatever plot of land you occupy, try to raise some food, and if possible become friendly with local farmers. No one can escape what is coming, as it will be global in nature, but you can take steps now to increase your chances of survival.

The Pursuit of Power

Humankind is imperfect. Individuals have always sought power, and power always corrupts. Power may be more addicting than drugs. The centralization of power within a political system has never ended well. The U.S. founding fathers designed a system of government to provide the needed checks and balances on power, and challenges to the Constitution continued after it was signed. The erosion of these checks and balances has contributed to the political and cultural divide within America.

Whitlock: America Was Built On Freedom, Opportunity, And Self-Determination And The Left Is Set On Destroying It All (Real Clear Politics)

Libs, welcome to the Resistance. Jack Cashill extends mercy to those finally acknowledging COVID tyranny (WND)

This post supports a secular and nonsecular approach to improvement that aligns with traditionally defined liberal and conservative values in the context of a Christian worldview. Traditionally defined liberals and conservatives support a love of their country and the Constitution including our origins, history, and mission. They have represented the political middle, but there may not be much of a “middle” these days. Braver Angels is one group working to “bridge the partisan divide and strengthen our democratic republic.” For more information on the left-vs-right divide, here are three short articles by Dennis Prager that discuss the issue:

A Guide to Basic Differences Between Left and Right 

Freedom Rallies

I spoke at the Southern Indiana Worldwide Freedom Rally that took place in Brown County, Indiana, on November 20, 2021. My speech, 2021_11_21_2 FINAL Speech Freedom Rally,
 received the expected ad hominem attacks as opposed to counterarguments from a few of my acquaintances with a more leftist perspective. A previous post on this topic provides some context: A Left Right Divide within Brown County, Indiana

hot

Complex and Controversial Issues and Topics

My speech at the rally incorporated both a conservative and a biblical worldview. And, of course, there was disagreement, opposite and opposing positions and philosophies. Note: Taking action to improve a process to achieve a more ideal outcome has a 100% success rate if you learn something new. But, it takes effort, time, patience, and commitment to work through the repeated cycles of a Plan, Do, Study, Act (PDSA) cycle. An example of an outline of a process that can be applied (and improved) to help work through the challenging issues can be read in this post: Quality-Technology-and-Abortion-Issue.

“The only fear that helps the world is the fear of God. But many prelates are instead paralyzed by fear of a virus.” – Freedom Rallies epitomize the modernist dream – so where are the Bishops?

Defeat The Mandates DC – United we stand, in peace we march.

The speakers, organizers, and people who showed up took huge risks in order to salvage what is left of the Founders’ vision. They deserve every credit for this. Bless them.”The DC Rally and the Rise of the Resistance

Spiritual Warfare

Good advice about stocking up, having some cash, and having paper (hard copy) documentation for information including bank and IRA accounts, etc. was given during the Sunday service on November 21, 2021, by Pastor Tim Conboy of New Life Community Church in Brown County, IN: Presentation (starts around 57:48) on the topics of The Great Reset and End Times. 

Pastor Conboy’s presentation on Globalism, The Great Reset, and Biblical Principals provides more background on the threat from globalists represented by the World Economic Forum. Significant among these is “cyber-COVID.” A follow-up on the topic regarding the digital equivalent of COVID includes a fictional” (worst-case) scenario for possible effects. Cyberwarfare is likely more of an option than EMP or Nuclear.

In his November 29, 2021 Sunday sermon, Crucifying Christ Again: Is The Apocalypse Now? Father John Echert draws an analogy between what’s going on globally today to what was happening inside the walls of Jerusalem in 70 AD. That was AN apocalypse. Is this THE apocalypse now? Looking at the signs of the times, Father argues that at the very least, the mystical body of Christ is entering into another passion very similar to that which Jesus Christ suffered 2000 years ago. What should we do? Well, here’s a hint: Of the estimated million people who were slaughtered by the Romans in 70 AD, not one Christian perished. Why? Well, that’s the point of this Sunday sermon. (Reference: Remnant Newspaper/TV)

Michael Matt, editor of Remnant Newspaper (Catholic), gave a lecture at the 2021 Roman Forum, “Band of Brothers: The Remnant and Other Warriors of the Movement.”  He covers the history of the split in the church between the traditional Catholics (counter-revolution – the tip of the spear) characterized by those that continue to support the Latin Mass and pre-Vatican II traditions and the New Mass and Church created from Vatican II. The Pope supports The Great Reset, Covid Policies (Plandemic) and a Global World Order.  Archbishop Viganò (a traditionalist—more references below) is one of the more outspoken members of the clergy opposing the Pope and his leadership.

NFL kicker who attends Latin Mass calls on Pope to stop persecuting traditional Catholics

Additional Perspectives

In December 2021, Norman Podhoretz published an opinion piece on the Spiritual War for America in the Wall Street Journal. He stated, “It’s a war, in my view. Many people are reluctant to see it in those terms. I mean, people say it’s a lot like 1858 and so on, but I don’t see it as a prelude to a civil war and 600,000 Americans dead. That’s not my meaning. But spiritually it’s a war.” Mr. Podhoretz keeps returning to the theme of war, a war made necessary, in his view, by the anti-Americanism of the political left. Is the hatred of America worse than it used to be? “Unquestionably,” he says. “This ‘woke’ business—Critical Race Theory, Black Lives Matter, all of it—is just pure anti-American hatred…We’re in a war, and it’s a war to the death. Now they actually admit it.”

Michael Anton wrote on Blue America’s Messaging Problem. He summed up their message: “We must rule you, punitively, forever—and if you so much as complain, you are literally Hitler. All shall love me and despair…That is Blue America’s message to Red. Whether or not it can succeed, and for how long, are the core political questions of our time.”

The Democrats’ exploitation of Jan. 6 gives away their game. Ben Shapiro suggests we call Jan. 6 for what it was: “an ugly but not pivotal moment in American history.” He goes on to say, “January 6 [2021], to opportunistic Democrats, is the all-purpose excuse to use the entire weight of their party to push for a radical revision of Senate rules and federal elections. Bob Unruh reported that an analysis by Real Clear Investigations found BLM riots caused 1,300 times as much damage as Jan. 6 violence, but there’s been “no comparable scrutiny.” Updated: Capitol-BLM Riots Side-by-Side Comparison (Real Clear Politics)

“Every Day Is Hunt Down Conservatives Day Now.” – New York Times telegraphs the left’s intent to use the January 6 anniversary to repress conservatives

Dick Cheney reappeared in the House of Representatives on the anniversary of January 6th, where the day was repeatedly described as a “coup” or an “insurrection” (instead of something closer to the American version of a soccer riot). Matt Taibbi’s article, A Tale of Two Authoritarians, says his reappearance helped identify the true villain on the scene.

The Greek word ‘pharmakia’ in Revelation 18. Michael Brown get exasperated with those who link reference to today’s Big Pharma

A quote from Finding real hope in a world gone mad. The one and only thing that can stop the Marxist revolution currently engulfing America: “Everything good about America,” said bestselling author and longtime Whistleblower Editor David Kupelian, “its Judeo-Christian culture, its Constitution, its exceptional level of personal liberty, Americans’ unique magnanimity and generosity, even their willingness to sacrifice their own lives and substance for the sake of others – are direct emanations of the Christian faith of its founding generation and the largely Christian citizenry and culture that have prevailed up until the current era.”

Trump’s Christmas message earns praise from Franklin Graham

Selwyn Duke compared the egos of Trump and Obama in God and Ego: Trump vs. Obama. Duke first shares a snippet of what Trump said while speaking at Dallas’s First Baptist Church in December 2021: “Our country has a Savior. And it’s not me …Remember that Jesus Christ is the ultimate source of our strength and our hope.” And then he compares that to an Obama interview in the Chicago Sun-Times during his 2004 Senate run: “While running for the U.S. Senate from Illinois in 2004, Obama was interviewed by Chicago Sun-Times religion reporter Cathleen Falsani, and what he revealed was striking, indeed. Obama spouted boilerplate leftist philoso-babble for much of the interview. One interesting point, however, was when Falsani asked him, ‘What is sin?’ Obama’s answer? ‘Being out of alignment with my values,’ he said.”

Text – Nov 20, 2021 Speech – Brown County Indiana Freedom Rally
Introduction

“Our Nation is in deep peril. We are in a fight for our survival as a Constitutional Republic like no other time since our founding in 1776. The conflict is between supporters of Socialism and Marxism vs. supporters of Constitutional freedom and liberty.” – Open Letter from Retired Generals and Admirals (May 2021)

America is under unprecedented attack. Challenges include a more pervasive belief that man and a larger, more tyrannical and controlling government inspired by Marxist philosophies and led by globalist elites will lead to man’s version of utopia. History, however, indicates that this “utopia” is hell on earth. The elites believe the failures and mistakes of past efforts by the elites of those times can be avoided through their unique brand of leadership in support of their vision of utopia. And, within any group of elites, there are always a few that work to further consolidate power under their leadership.

Marx’s socialist theories are all based on a fundamental belief in the existence of God, but a hatred and opposition to everything God has taught.”Pastor: Do Champions of Socialism Realize That Karl Marx Held a Deep Belief in God?

Marxist Revolution in the Making in America, Expert Warns

Biblical prophecy identifies that humans are not basically good. We are all sinners (imperfect). Another insight is that some humans will continually seek to gain, centralize, and abuse power. In a political context, this eventually leads to a “one-world” (global) government that the antichrist will control, followed by Armageddon. Armageddon is the final battle between good and evil. As prophesized, Jesus Christ will return and defeat evil. He establishes peace on earth for one thousand years and then for eternity. “But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.” – Mathew 13:32, NIV

The United States is a secular country whose design was influenced by Judeo-Christian principles. Our founders, many of whom were Christians, understood the Bible, lessons from history, and insight into human nature. The Constitution includes built-in checks and balances on power. The Bill of (Human) Rights empowers “We the People” [top management] to work together in pursuit of “a more perfect Union.” This requires that changes result in outcomes where everyone benefits (more needs are met), or at least, are not any worse off in the long term. This is in contrast to our current situation where actions motivated by hate and contempt are taken to divide, weaken, destroy, and transform the country.

Differences Between a Secular and a Religious – Jewish or Christian – Upbringing (by Dennis Prager)

The eternal lust for power. Patrice Lewis cites 5 factors that enable politicians to wield control over others

Socialism: The worst bad idea in history – A wake-up call for young people enamored with leftism

Regarding the term “perfect,” in the Christian context, only God is perfect; man is imperfect and expected to improve. Jesus Christ is the standard of perfection. These facts align with the principles of continuous improvement and quality management. Reducing variation from the ideal (more perfect) leads to more needs being met and less harm on people when needs are not met. Additional information can be found here: Success through Quality.

Challenges to the Constitution continued after it was signed into law. These challenges contributed to Benjamin Franklin’s response to a group of citizens asking what sort of government the delegates had created. His reply: “A republic, if you can keep it.” 

Have We “Kept It?”

The checks and balances on power have been slowly eroded to the extent the U.S. may now be functioning more as an oligarchy than a republic. Key findings from a study referenced at Represent.US concluded the following:

… data from nearly 2000 public opinion surveys … compared what the public wanted to what the government actually did. What they found was extremely unsettling: The opinions of 90% of Americans have essentially no impact at all.”

This erosion of the checks and balances on power manifests in the harm caused today by the leftist strategies and policies pursued by the current administration and its allies.

The Constitution and Bill of Rights are our last line of defense and provide citizens the power to fight back against the policies of the Leftists and to mitigate their destructive effects. We can work together within our local community to work through these turbulent and chaotic times while strengthening our republic. Eventually, there will be a transition to The Better Times – the banishment of evil and peace on earth—in other words, THE GREATEST RESET.

“Political tags – such as royalist, communist, democrat, populist, fascist, liberal,
conservative, and so forth – are never basic criteria. The human race divides
politically into those who want people to be controlled and those who have
no such desire.” 
– Robert A. Heinlein, The Notebooks of Lazarus Long

The Global Threat from the Elites: World Economic Forum (WEF)
The Great Reset and Build Back Better

Klaus Schwab’s vision of a post-COVID world, and how the economy can work with nature – The Great Reset podcast

Covid-19 was a known and anticipated risk. So, too, is the digital equivalent.” – What the COVID-19 pandemic teaches us about cybersecurity – and how to prepare for the inevitable global cyberattack

Three Scenarios – Action, Reaction, Counteraction

“Freedom is a fragile thing and it’s never more than one generation away from extinction. It is not ours by way of inheritance: it must be fought for and defended constantly by each generation, for it comes only once to a people.” –Ronald Reagan

Scenarios are a good way to provide a context to help understand the conflicts associated with current events, including the political and cultural divides. Projections of what might happen in the future include current actions and reactions to these events, leading to counteractions.

As stated earlier, traditionally defined liberals and conservatives support a love of their country and the Constitution to include our origins, history, and mission. They have been considered as representing the political center. The aim of this post is to support the application of principles, methods, and actions that can result in outcomes where everyone can benefit, or at least, are not any worse off in the long term.

“What happens when the common ground of core values is lost?” –America’s future after the political center’s disappearance.

Prager: The Left Is Evil—And Liberals Keep Voting for Them

Why I condemn liberals without apology. Exclusive: Mychal Massie blasts the codification of ‘adherence to insanity’ vis-a-vis gender

In contrast to policies that unite (E Pluribus Unum), national policies ceding more power and control to the government to include unjustified mandates are destructive and divisive, and they negatively affect all Americans and liberty-loving people worldwide.

Actions – Biden Administration

This includes leftist policies including “Build Back Better” that align with The Great Reset. This scenario reflects the desire for an expansion and centralization of government control (more power in the hands of the few) in all aspects of life with the belief that the leftist vision of utopia is best for America. These policies are like a virus that is deliberately aimed to weaken and destroy the country. Klaus Schwab’s The Great Reset outlines the globalist, elitist, and deep state positions as opposed to national interests.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi thinks America is just so very, very lucky in these trying times. The House speaker, contrary to most public opinion polls, heaped praise upon President Biden and his job performance, even saying the President is “just perfect.”

In November, Global leaders including President Biden, European Commission President Von Der Leyen, and UK Prime Minister Johnson announced their commitment to addressing the climate crisis through infrastructure development. They discussed how the Build Back Better, World Global Gateway, and Clean Green Initiatives will jumpstart investments, sharpen focus, and mobilize resources to meet critical infrastructure needs to support economic growth, while ensuring that this infrastructure is clean, resilient, and consistent with a net-zero future.

In June, 2021, the Biden administration released the first-ever National Strategy for Countering Domestic Terrorism to address this challenge to America’s national security and improve the federal government’s response. A 100-day comprehensive review completed as directed by President Biden found “the two most lethal elements of today’s domestic terrorism threat are (1) racially or ethnically motivated violent extremists who advocate for the superiority of the white race and (2) anti-government or anti-authority violent extremists, such as militia violent extremists.

Democrats have been indulging in the ultimate gaslighting over the last couple years by painting ordinary law-abiding citizens as domestic terrorists. If you burn down a community in the name of George Floyd, you’re celebrated. If you speak at school board meetings, you’re a domestic terrorist. – Revealed: The REAL insurrection transforming U.S. into darkness, Branding normal Americans as ‘terrorists,’ Democrats pursue total revolution

Greetings from your friendly neighborhood domestic terrorist. Patrice Lewis invites FBI to surveil her engaging in ‘deplorable’ activities

How Close Is Total Social and Economic Collapse?

White House Sells ‘Life of Linda’ to Promote Socialist Cradle-to-Grave Government

Michael Yon and Masako Ganaha discuss Globalist Mass Disorder with Jason Morgan (Remnant Columnist) in The Weaponization of Human Beings: “What’s clear is that the United States is being invaded. Globalists in Washington, DC, are working with globalists elsewhere in the world to invade America. Human beings are being weaponized for globalist and also for American political ends...There is no truth without context. Right now, the contextualized truth is that the United States and much of the rest of the world is under sustained, planned attack by globalists.”

Jonathan Turley: Biden’s Supreme Court ‘diversity’ criteria ‘unconstitutional’

Chinese elite have paid some $31 million to Hunter and the Bidens

Reaction – Populist (Republican/Political Middle) Counteraction

This includes working to gain control of Congress in 2022 and 2024 and the Presidency in 2024. A priority is to work to ensure election integrity and counter the attacks on America by the Leftists. The expectation is to reverse the push toward socialism and restore the Constitutional Republic and the rule of law. Given the political and cultural differences, this will unlikely bridge the divides in the country and may increase them. What is needed is an optimal and comprehensive strategy that can be successfully applied locally as well as nationally and globally. The Brown County Leader Network provides examples of a strategy, methods, and tools for supporting improvement.

Victor Davis Hanson: Please — stop the coup porn An op-ed in response to a Washington Post op-ed in which three retired generals warn of supposed impending coup should Trump be elected again in 2024.

The American people are telling the Big Government Socialists, ‘No, this is not the future we want.'” – Newt Gingrich: What GOP victories in Virginia and beyond tell us about the future

Election Cycles – Change Without Improvement?

“First, modern American elections are about change. In 2008 we got Barack Obama. In 2010 we got a huge backlash to Obama in the midterms. In 2012 we got backlash to the backlash, and Obama won again easily. In 2014, we saw Democrats get creamed again. In 2016, after eight years of Obama, we got the ultimate change: Donald J. Trump. In 2018 we had a midterms backlash to Trump. In 2020 we got a second backlash to Trump with Joe Biden. And so in 2021 and 2022. What would you guess is going to happen?” Isaac Saul, Tangle

Former Trump campaign manager and chief strategist Steve Bannon discussed preparing to select four thousand new hires and political appointees with Trump loyalists and political appointees to make and sustain needed changes: Media Meltdown After Steve Bannon Again Calls for Army of GOP Operatives to Overhaul Government (Video)

Reclaiming our country and our freedom: Is it possible? Laura Hollis asserts ‘Americans are mad as hell and aren’t going to take it anymore’

Counteraction – Christian Worldview and The Great Reset

Biblical prophecy indicates the emergence of a one-world (global) government that is controlled by the antichrist. Israel is at the center of Armageddon. After a period of turmoil and tribulations, Jesus Christ restores order and establishes peace on earth for a thousand years and then for eternity, e.g., The Better Times. Individuals who choose to embrace the Christian faith gain eternal life. “For God so loved the world, that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life.” (John 3:16, NIV)

The transition to a one-world (global) government is not expected to be an easy transition.

“Then he said to them, “Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom. There will be great earthquakes, and in various places famines and pestilences. And there will be terrors and great signs from heaven.” (Luke 21:10-11)

The United States is not inferred in Revelations as coming to the aid of Israel in the final battle, which begs the question, what happens to and in America? Further questions: How does the world and the United States transition to this one-world (global) government? What would be the indicators? 

The End Times and The Great Reset

“Modern history is the dialogue between two men: one who believes in God,and another who believes he is a god.” – Nicolás Gómez Dávila

Christian faith includes the belief that actions motivated by love will result in outcomes where everyone benefits or at least, or not any worse off in the long term. The End Times will lead to The Better Times.

Does the Bible prophesy a one-world government and a one-world currency in the end times? The Bible does not use the phrase “one-world government” or “one-world currency” in referring to the End Times. It does, however, provide ample evidence to enable us to draw the conclusion that both will exist under the rule of the Antichrist in the last days.” (Reference: GotQuestions.org)

Love never fails.” – 1 Corinthians 13:8, NIV

Anti-God – Satanic

Marxist principles serve as the foundation for political policies and systems, including progressivism, socialism, and communism. A core belief is that man, not God, can create a moral standard and a utopia on Earth. “Cultural Marxism views primary human identity in terms of opposing oppressor/oppressed groups along the axes of race, class, sexuality, gender, etc., granting special knowledge found only in the ‘lived experience’ of the oppressed.”  These beliefs and resulting actions have never worked and contributed to millions of deaths. Marx was raised in a Christian home but later abandoned God and associated with Satan. Marx declared: “I long to take vengeance on the One Who rules from above … We make war against all prevailing ideas of religion, of the state, of country, of patriotism.”  

Saul Alinsky’s book, Rules for Radicals has been referred as the bible of the progressives. Alinsky references the contributions of Lucifer. Lucifer was one of God’s angels who chose evil and became Satan. “Lest we forget at least an over-the-shoulder acknowledgment to the very first radical: from all our legends, mythology, and history (and who is to know where mythology leaves off and history begins—or which is which), the first radical known to man who rebelled against the establishment and did it so effectively that he at least won his own kingdom.” — Lucifer.

Rules for Radicals inspired the development of the Cloward-Piven Strategy which aims to overload the public welfare system that creates a crisis. The crisis expected to lead to support for universal basic income.

Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom.”
(2 Corinthians 3:17, NIV)

Biden ramps up attack on religious freedoms under First Amendment

“Plandemic”?

Klaus Schwab’s The Great Reset outlines the globalist, elitist, and deep state positions for controlling the world as opposed to national interests.

John Hopkins University and the Bill and Melissa Gates Foundation hosted a A Global Pandemic Exercise in October 2019.

“COVID-19 has accelerated our transition into the age of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. We have to make sure that the new technologies in the digital, biological and physical world remain human-centred and serve society as a whole, providing everyone with fair access” – The Great Reset: A Unique Twin Summit to Begin 2021

COVID-19: The Great Reset can be purchased on Amazon in paperback. It’s a guide for anyone who wants to understand how COVID-19 disrupted our social and economic systems, and what changes will be needed to create a more inclusive, resilient and sustainable world going forward.

“What they mean by The Great Reset is exactly what they warned that Agenda 21 was all about – the reorganization of human society. That means a massive change, or the outright elimination, of our economy, income sources and jobs, private property, personal privacy, individual choice, families as we know them, information sources, communication, entertainment, energy source and use, education process, food source, housing, cities, farms, health care, national sovereignty, and our system of government. And the goal is to accomplish it all by 2030. Now, how could that be possible?” What the great reset will really do to you

WORLD VACCINATION: Michael Matt on the Kennedy Connection. This video also contains a preview of Robert F. Kennedy’s book The Real Anthony Fauci which “details how Fauci, Gates, and their cohorts use their control of media outlets, scientific journals, key government and quasi-governmental agencies, global intelligence agencies, and influential scientists and physicians to flood the public with fearful propaganda about COVID-19 virulence and pathogenesis, and to muzzle debate and ruthlessly censor dissent.”

The Better Policies for Covid?

The Great Barrington Declaration recommends “Focused protection” for those at most risk. It supported the development of policies in Florida and Sweden—no mandates or shutdowns—and provides available treatments to the vaccinated and unvaccinated.

Covid-19 natural immunity compared to vaccine-induced immunity: The definitive summary

Yale epidemiologist Dr. Harvey Risch argues COVID-19 is a Pandemic of Fear ‘Manufactured’ by Authorities. He states, “By and large, it’s been a very selected pandemic, and predictable. It was very distinguished between young versus old, healthy versus chronic disease people. So we quickly learned who was at risk for the pandemic and who wasn’t…However, the fear was manufactured for everybody. And that’s what’s characterized the whole pandemic is that degree of fear and people’s response to the fear.” Risch also shared data on the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine, Ivermectin, and other therapeutics used to treat COVID-19. He has authored over 300 peer-reviewed publications and has served on the board of editors for the American Journal of Epidemiology.

Adversaries – Global vs National Interests and Sovereignty

adversary: “Someone who offers opposition”

We are five days away from fundamentally transforming the United States of America.”
– 
Barack Obama in Columbia, Missouri on October 30, 2008.

Adversaries representing opposing positions and policies include the following: The global elites including some American billionaires, politicians, academia, and government officials who support The Great Reset; the “woke” corporations and their CEOs who embrace globalist vs. nationalist interests; big tech, big pharma, and the leftist legacy media; the Biden administration and its officials who are executing the Marxist-based progressive policies envisioned by the Obama administration to support their aim of “transforming America” to a socialist state managed by the “elite”; The political and administrative deep state—Rinos and Dinos; and the naive, apathetic, and disinterested Americans who do not recognize the scope and effect of the fundamental changes supported through executive orders, legislation, and regulations.

It’s Not the Malevolent Few. It’s the Complacent Many

Strategy and Tactics?

This includes actions by any individual and group (government and non-government) that weaken the country. The intent is to facilitate submission to a socialist government and rule by the elites. In the interim, weakness makes us vulnerable to attacks by our foreign adversaries, such as China and Russia.

Are China and Russia Already at War With Us?

When reading and learning more about the “state of America” via the media, social media platforms, et al., the volume and variety of attacks on America can be perceived as being overwhelming. This is the intent where it is hoped citizens will give up and accept their fate.

The left is addicted to projection—the psycho-political syndrome of attributing all of one’s own sins to one’s opponentsWhy The Left Always Projects

How Borderline Personality Disorder helps explain the left

Jason Whitlock argues the corporate media outlets are using racial division to fertilize a revolution financed by billionaire elitists as a means of dismantling America as we know it: The pursuit of ‘racial justice’ camouflages the revolution of American corporate media support

Attacks on our strengths can be categorized into areas that include Constitutional, Diplomatic, Political, Military, National Security, Domestic Tranquility and Security, Economic, Social, Information, Environment, Communications, Infrastructure, Legal, Education, Culture, Energy, Illegal Immigration, Health, Food, and Religion.

Quality-driven and Christian-supported changes are intended to lead to outcomes where everyone (all stakeholders) benefit or at least are not any worse off in the long term. In contrast, Leftist policies have resulted in: increased Illegal immigration, unsecured borders, increasing crime, increased spending and debt, increasing inflation including higher energy and food prices, wokeism, de-platforming, canceling, censorship, reductions in small businesses (the lifeblood our economy), suppression of information by Big Tech, election integrity, Afghanistan, identify politics (social justice, Critical Race Theory), tyrannical COVID-19 policies and mandates, weaker military and national security, green new deals, attack on history and culture, and overall, a greater division and polarity within America. Divide and conquer has usually been a successful strategy.

The U.S. military uses a variety of tools, such as ASCOPE/PMESII to help organize and assess external threats and vulnerabilities. The same tools can be used to assess internal challenges. There are also a variety of methods and tools used within the quality profession to help assess, identify and prioritize improvement opportunities that will achieve the best results with the least amount of resources.

Chicago Chaos: A Warning for America?

Americans Outraged Over Secret Biden Airlift Of Illegals

Florida governor Ron DeSantis summarized our current situation and offered strategies for meeting the challenges in a speech delivered at the Claremont Institute Gala in 2021. The American Mind published excerpts of the speech, which can be found here: Opposing Tyranny. DeSantis spoke of Dwight Eisenhower’s warning about the increasing prevalence of scientific research intermingling with government money and reminded listeners that “the job of a statesman is not to allow policy to be held captive by one faction of society, but to harmonize all the competing interests and to make sure that you’re leading on behalf of the entire country, or, in [his] case, entire state.”

DeSantis has also made his position clear regarding Critical Race Theory and “cultural Marxism,” vowing that Florida will not tolerate the left’s pursuit of wokeness. Florida’s COVID-19 policies were guided by the Great Barrington Declaration.

“The philosophy of the schoolroom in one generation will
become the philosophy of the government in the next.”
 – Abraham Lincoln

Vaccines, Mandates, Shutdowns – The Great Reset

COVID-19 is being leveraged to support the structural changes in our culture that will undermine individual rights as guaranteed by the Constitution and Bill of Rights. The lack of trust and transparency on vaccine efficacy, censorship on successful treatments with available drugs, undermining adverse effects, and discounting the value of natural immunity has led to charges by physicians that COVID-19 policies represent potential crimes against humanity. The lack of action and follow-up on cases and indicators available through VAERS reinforces the allegations that crimes may be being committed.

“The evidence is in. Governors, journalists, scientists, university presidents, hospital administrators, and business leaders can continue to follow Dr. Anthony Fauci or open their eyes. After 700,000-plus COVID deaths and the devastating effects of lockdowns, it is time to return to basic principles of public health.” – How Fauci Fooled America

The COVID Blitzkrieg: Can our liberties be restored?

Columbia study: True U.S. COVID vaccine death count is 400,000

Dr. Peter McCullough was among the first doctors to immediately and successfully treat COVID-19 patients with available drugs and prevent hospitalizations. For his efforts, he has been censored and canceled. In this presentation, Dr. McCullough reinforces the case that the vaccines and mandates are not so much about health but power and control. In his presentation, McCullough endorses the book COVID-19 and the Global-Predators: We Are the Prey which supports the argument that global and national COVID-19 policies are part of a larger plan in support of The Great Reset.

A theory regarding the depopulation aspect of the “plandemic” in support of a great reset is discussed in the article Why are they Killing us?, posted at The Buring Platform, Jan 26, 2022. The article includes strategies for countering the attacks with the conclusion referencing Romans 8:31, NIV: “What, then, shall we say in response to these things? If God is for us, who can be against us?

Pope Francis Says Global Reset Is Real: No ‘Return to Normality’ After the Pandemic.

False Religions

In a speech delivered virtually to the Congress of Catholics and Public Life in Madrid, the archbishop of Los Angeles argued America’s new political religions like ‘social justice,’ ‘wokeness,’ ‘identity politics’ and ‘intersectionality’ have come to “fill the space that Christian belief and practice once occupied.” – Top Catholic bishop calls wokeness and identity politics’ pseudo-religions’. He said, “An elite leadership class has risen in our countries that have little interest in religion and no real attachments to the nations they live in or to local traditions or cultures …”

The Way Forward for Church and Country: A Catholic Bishop Diagnoses Woke and Prescribes Faith, Hope, and Love

Why Wokeism Is a Religion

Counter Actions and Mitigation Strategies

“You will hear of wars and rumors of wars, but see to it that you are not alarmed.
These things must happen, but the end is still to come. Nation will rise against nation,
and kingdom against kingdom. There will be famines and earthquakes in various places…All these are the beginning of birth pains.” 
(Mark 13:1–8; Luke 21:5–9)

Archbishop Viganò delivers a message for Truth for Health Foundation in which he reinforces what is currently happening (and prophesized in the Bible), including the harm caused by The Great Reset, the vaccines, and mandates. He also reinforces our responsibility for noncompliance (fighting the mandates and abuse of power) and the role of preparation and prayer to help us get through the coming hard times. Dr. McCullough’s presentation (mentioned earlier) also references the strategy for controlling populations through IDs/passports and health care.

“Vaccine Victims are Sacrificed at the Altar of Moloch”

In a stunning letter on the vaccine program penned by Viganò, the archbishop slams the Pope for promoting jabs that contain material from aborted fetuses (Note: other sources have stated that abortion-derived cell lines have been used in testing for some vaccines. See also Thomas More Society). He shared other concerns regarding COVID-19 treatment as well, such as drug treatments that have been proven effective without the risk of a vaccine and a concern for serious side effects possible with the experimental vaccine. Further, Viganò also questions the use of the term “vaccine” when it has been proven ineffective in preventing and transmitting the disease, and expresses his fury at other members of the clergy and Pope Francis for facilitating a “crime against humanity” and “satanic action against God.”

Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò Calls on People of Faith to Unite in a Worldwide Anti-Globalist Alliance to Free Humanity from the Totalitarian Regime (VIDEO)

Website that Publishes Archbishop Viganò’s Speeches and Video Is Taken Down – Three Weeks After He Calls for Worldwide Conference Against the Globalist Threat

Malachy’s Last Pope Identified – in Bible Prophecy

Pope Francis celebrates five openly Marxist organizations

In an interview with Larry Tomczak, author Dr. Michael Brown talks about a nation “on the threshold of a major collapse.” Dr. Brown says that the answer to the question “Is revival exploding across America?” is both “yes and no” to be precise and respond in integrity. Revival is not sweeping across America in this time of national crisis, but we are experiencing places where the “holy fire” of God is falling.

A great collapse this winter? President Biden warned that 2021/22 would include at “dark winter” in the face of the coronavirus pandemic. Scott Lively says rebuilding a healthy church network is the best way to get through it.

Tracking the globalist propaganda shift on COVID

A Way Ahead – Action Plan

…and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty. (2 Corinthians, 3:17, KJV)

“Let us with caution indulge the supposition that morality can be maintained without religion. Whatever may be conceded to the influence of refined education on minds of peculiar structure, reason and experience both forbid us to expect that national morality can prevail in exclusion of religious principle.” – George Washington’s farewell address

Actions can include

  • push-backs, protests, freedom rallies, noncompliance with mandates, legislative action, lawsuits, voting, information, and networking.
  • Develop and implement a Community Quality Strategy involving leaders from all stakeholder groups
  • Prayer.
  • Support the local community of Christians and sharing the Gospel.
  • Prepare for the hard times that could occur in local communities to ensure continued access to food, water, energy, communication, sanitation, medicine, security.
  • Get political. Support and vote for Christian-based policies guided by the Bible and The Constitution.
    • Christian-based change principle: Changes motivated by love (first, do no harm) will lead to outcomes where everyone can benefit, or at least, are not any worse off in the long term.
    • A monopoly on political power is never a good thing. Transparency and performance plans help to mitigate the tendency for elected and appointed officials to make decision that support the few at the expense of the many.
  • Support the application of the quality improvement principles, methods, and tools that can help ensure that changes will result in improvement.
    • The Brown County Leader Network (BCLN) supports a secular and nonsecular approach to improvement. This includes supporting assessments, decision-making, strategic planning and execution, and the application of quality improvement methods and tools.
    • One application could be support for churches interested in sharing the Gospel throughout the community — see Share the good news above.

Additional and Supporting Information

“To win one hundred victories in one hundred battles is not the acme of skill.
To subdue the enemy without fighting is the acme of skill.”
 – Sun Tzu, The Art of War

A timeline of events:

  • September–November 2019: Issues at Wuhan Lab. Air handling equipment installed, database taken off-line, air incinerator requested in December.
  • October 2019: World Military Games are held in Wuhan, China. Ten thousand athletes from 100 countries attend. Wuhan streets are vacant of citizens.
  • December 2019: COVID-19 cases appear in China. In late December, the coverup begins. On December 31, China reports problems to WHO. China falsely reports no human-to-human transmission. The pandemic begins.

Censorship and Coverup:

  • US funds gain of function (man-made virus)
  • Govt owns patents yet pays full price for vaccines.

58 Percent of Americans Believe in God as Described in the Bible (Pew Research Center poll)

COVID-19 A Pandemic of Fear ‘Manufactured’ by Authorities

Fear Is Deadlier Than Viruses

Crimes or Cover-Up? Exposing the World’s Most Dangerous Lie

Other Suggested Reading:

American Marxism by Mark R. Levin

Irresistible Revolution: Marxism’s Goal of Conquest & the Unmaking of the American Military by Matthew Lohmeier

Success Through Quality by Tim Clark

U.S. city abandons political correctness, goes non-stop for God 24 hours a day

A Way Ahead for America

Independent Voters of Brown County IN

Covid – Strengthening the Immune System, Treatments, Vaccine Injuries, Mandates, Exceptions

A Left-Right Divide within Brown County, Indiana

Is America in The Midst of a Cold Civil War?

American Civics – County, State, Nation

New American civil war ‘not terribly unlikely,‘ analysis warns

          We Are in a World War. It Is a Fifth Generation War

America is an experiment in self-government under God. Our founders designed the foundation of this country so that we would be a self-governing people. Self-government under God leads to greater freedom, and the converse is also true: bigger government under Man constricts our freedom. – The American Experiment: Will self-government survive?

Has the 2nd American Revolution already begun?

    • Americans across the land are awakening to realize the urgency of the hour and destiny for the church in this, the anticipated ‘evil day.’ It really is time for a second American Revolution/Civil War!” –

The Great End Times Salvation Search-and-Rescue  Exclusive: Scott Lively asserts, ‘2022 will be a year of apostasy and tribulation-driven revival’

RFK Jr tells Carlson all of Bill of Rights violated during the pandemic except 2nd amendment

    • “The rise of censorship, the rise of the suppression of religious freedoms, of property rights, closing a million businesses without just compensation or due process, the abolition of jury trials, which are guaranteed by the Sixth and Seventh Amendment for any vaccine company that hurts you, all of these — and the rise of a kind of track-and-trace surveillance state has been troubling to people, both Democrats and Republicans”

What will be the effects after more than half the country loses faith in the pillars of American civilization? Losing Confidence in the Pillars of Our Civilization by Victor David Hanson

Orchestrating a collapse by Patrice Lewis, WND …  “From an ideologue’s perspective, destruction is the whole point.”

Will 2022 Midterms Be the Next Great Crisis Backlash?

    • “At least twice in U.S. history, big political shakeups occurred in midterm elections that served as endpoints to periods of crisis, privation, and extraordinary government expansion and regimentation.” 

It is time to stop passively encouraging totalitarianism Exclusive: Brian Ray challenges Americans to pay the price of resisting government dictates

Victor Davis Hanson makes some interesting points in Third-Worldizing America:

    • “Third-Worldization reflects the asymmetry of law enforcement. Ideology and money, not the law, adjudicate who gets arrested and tried, and who does not. There were 120 days of continuous looting, arson, and lethal violence during the summer of 2020. Rioters burned courthouses, police precincts, and an iconic church. And there was also a frightening riot on January 6, when a mob entered Washington D.C.’s Capitol and damaged federal property. Of those arrested during the violence [of Jan 6], many have been held in solitary confinement or under harsh jail conditions. That one-day riot is currently the subject of a congressional investigation. Some of those arrested are still…awaiting trial. The convicted are facing long prison sentences. In contrast, some 14,000 were arrested in the longer and more violent rioting of 2020. Most were released without bail. The majority had their charges dropped. Very few are still being held awaiting capital charges. A common denominator to recent controversies at the Justice Department, CIA, FBI, and Pentagon is that all these agencies under dubious pretexts have investigated American citizens with little or no justification – after demonizing their targets as ‘treasonous,’ ‘domestic terrorists,’ ‘white supremacists,’ or ‘racists.’

Hedge fund founder Ray Dalio predicts there is a 30% chance of US Civil War in the next 10 years because of ’emotional’ political polarization: Believes the Constitution may save the nation

Why Did So Many Doctors Become Nazis?

“Studies suggest mass formation follows a general distribution: 30% are brainwashed, hypnotized, indoctrinated by the group narrative. 40% in the middle are persuadable and may follow if no worthy alternative is perceived. 30% fight against the narrative.” Dr. Robert Malone explains the phenomenon in Mass Formation Psychosis.

Brent Smith spotlights other nations without a Bill of Rights succumbing to “Covidstan” – The Founding Fathers save us again!

We are living amidst a Cold Civil War. This is a war not over the size of government or taxes, but over the American way of life. Winning this war requires fundamental understandings. For starters, you must understand that you are, in fact, in a war.” –Defending The American Way Of Life During A Cold Civil War (Video)

In March 2020, Dr. Zelenko’s team was one of the first in the country to successfully treat thousands of Covid-19 patients in the prehospital setting. Dr. Zelenko developed his now famous Zelenko Protocol, which has saved countless lives worldwide with an estimated 99% survival of high risk Covid-19 patients.– Re-Awaken American – Dr. Zelenko

Michael Lind theorizes that American progressives are becoming more like those in the French Jacobin tradition, but qualifies his thesis to include saying so would be an insult to the French: How American Progressives Became French Jacobins

“Woke” America is turnout our country into a totalitarian police state: Rittenhouse, Smollett, and the Big Lie Eating Away at America

New Retail Project – Special Exception for the Proposed 185 Site Luxury RV Park Denied – For the Record

BlueElk

New Retail Project

Nov 8, 2021.  Nashville responsible for changing the zoning to B3 when the property was annexed. Per the County Planning Department, “Legislative bodies (in this case the Town Council) have the power to change zoning designations during Annexation procedures without input from the Plan Commission.”

  • This begs the question: What was the process used by the council to make this change? What was the legal basis and required steps? Were public meetings held? Were neighbors notified? Is documentation available?

Nov 4, 2021.  Nashville Technical Review Committee — 1 p.m., Town Hall. Agenda includes review of new buildings project by Stephen Alexander at 1415 East Old State Road 46.

  • DRC/Technical Review Board Meeting – Notes. The developers will be putting in two retail buildings in separate locations on the property and a swimming pool. No specifics on the type of retail were provided. The design will be a “Farmstead Look.” The building will be on the north side of Salt Creek in a “Flood Fringe area. Per the town, they can be hooked up to the sewers. And before getting building permits, they will have to meet all requirements to include  flood-way related issues. Not much anyone can do regarding the development. One of the buildings will be 3,700 sq.ft. and the other 4,000. Utility building is 1500 sq.ft.
  • BCM Facebook Post on the topic

Nov 2, 2021. Zoning boards approve, deny different tourism attractions By Staff Reports 

  • …   the Brown County Board of Zoning Appeals denied a special exception to allow a 185 spot luxury RV campground.

    The Salmon Room at the Brown County Office Building was full on Oct. 27 with around 40 residents.

    Over an hour 23 residents spoke against the proposed project with most of them living on or owning property near the proposed park area in a field off of Old State Road 46 near the intersection of Clay Lick Road.

    The petitioner, Stephen Alexander, was requesting a special exception for a private recreational development on 20 acres of his 71.76 acre parcel.

    The property is located within town limits and is zoned business (B3), which is a service and warehouse business use designation. Under that zoning all general business uses are allowed along with a commercial parking structure, car sales room, drive-in restaurants, storage warehouse, filling station and tourist home, according to the town’s zoning ordinance.

    The property is also in the floodway. Alexander has owned the field where the proposed park was going to go for 30 years.

    Proposed “new buildings” at Alexander’s Old 46 property are on the agenda for project review at the Nashville Technical Review Committee this Thursday, Nov. 4. The meeting is at 1 p.m. in the Nashville Town Hall, 200 Commercial Street.

  

Oct 29, 2021. I checked with the County Planning Office. They are the ones that approve any building permits in the B3 Zone. They provided the following information:

  • A few uses would not require building permits such as creating a public park with no structures. Any use that is considered development in the Floodplain (Fringe areas) would need local floodplain permits. Development in areas of the Floodway district would require permits from the DNR Water Division and local Floodplain Permits. Any structures over 400 square feet to be placed in the FF or FW would have to meet elevation requirements with the lowest floor being elevated to at least 2 feet above base flood elevation (BFE) or for commercial buildings, floodproofed by either elevation or mechanical means. In addition to floodplain permits and building permits for structures, the Nashville DRC would be involved in granting or denying certificates of appropriateness.

    Building permit questions to Lonnie Farlee if you wish to ask about code requirements for commercial buildings.

    Nashville also has a floodplain ordinance in Town Jurisdiction.

Oct 27, 2021. BZA Meeting. Unanimous NO vote. Brown  County residents at their finest provide “expert testimony” as to the issues and harmful impacts associated with this development.
  • If the BZA did not approve the special exception, developer threatened a “Plan B” where he could support projects that comply with the existing Gneral Business (GB) B3 Zoning – Service and Warehouse Business Use, without needing BZA Approval.

    • HOWEVER, He will need building permits that are approved by the County!  

Facebook Comments:  Brown County Matters and Brown County Chatter.

Note: We would have fewer conflicting opinions on topics such as this if we had a better Comprehensive Plan. Ours is 14 pages – around 100 would be more appropriate. Vagueness and generalities can be interpreted both ways. Although the plan meets minimum state requirements, it is immoral and unethical to have a plan used for decisions that does not represent the “Voice” of the residents.

Statement Tim J Clark 185 Site RV PARK Proposal – Forwarded via email to the BZA Board via The Planning Commission on 10/27/2021 at 10:53 am

Oct 27, 2021

 Dear BZA Board,

Based on a review of the County Comprehensive Plan, the submitted project documents, and comments from citizens posted on two Brown County Specific Facebook pages – Brown County Matters and Brown County Chatter (see enclosures), I do not believe this project as described in the submitted documents, is in alignment with the County Comprehensive Plan and in the best interests of the county.

Regarding the Facebook comments, I provided a copy (enclosures) in PDF files to allow for a quick review.  The original posts as well as reactions can be easily viewed on the respective Facebook group pages.

This 185 Site RV Park supports more tourism. A vision for more tourism is not specifically addressed in the County Comprehensive Plan. When is more tourism too much for the infrastructure (including roads) and acceptable by county residents? Andy Rogers recognized the importance of maintaining a balance. His vision was to accommodate tourism and not destroy the culture and “soul” of the county:

  • “People say, ‘Well, we can’t change.’ But we can change and still retain some of the flavor of Brown County. We need people to live here. I’m in the tourist business but we don’t want to turn this town over to the tourists. You can go to Gatlinburg if you want to see what happens to a town that turns it all over to business. It’s not a town anymore—it’s a shopping center.

     

  • “We don’t need to be slick and highly commercial. We need to be more country. Country is what we sell…. We need to maintain that. Once you destroy that, it won’t come back.”

 The County Comprehensive Plan (14 pages) represents the “Voice” of the residents. Although it meets the minimum requirements by the state, it is too short and vague. This allows for “flexibility” where arguments for or against a project can be equally valid. The plan does not provide the level of specificity that should be needed to make the best decision regarding the proposed 185 Site RV park. The plan does not specifically mention support for a project of this scope to be located on land that is used for agriculture and homes.

Specific Comments – Alignment with the Comprehensive Plan:

01. The 185 Site RV Park is not in alignment with the Count Comprehensive Plan (CCP). The plan mission statement identifies the following: “To provide guidance on decision making regarding Brown County land use, public service and zoning that enhances the quality of life for the residents based on the county’s natural beauty and rural atmosphere.”

  • How does this project enhance the quality of life for “residents”? Why would a 185 site RV (mobile home) Park be considered an enhancement to the “natural beauty and rural atmosphere”?
  • Enclosures 1 and 2 identify the comments from residents sharing their “Voice” regarding the project. Those that are opposed or have concerns provide more detail regarding their position than the individuals that just commented that they were in favor of the project.

02.  Plan -Introduction. “There is a special need to understand that planning should identify and encourage those land uses that have been positive over time, especially those that contribute to the distinctive character of this “special place” called Brown County. Planning can guard against rapid change and growth that are incompatible with existing infrastructure and the county’s “quality of life vision.

  • There is no history or evidence of how an RV Park of this size has had a positive influence in the county.
  • How does a 185 Site RV Park add to the distinctive character of this “special place called Brown County” or “quality of life vision”? This project supports tourism, e.g., more visitors – NOT residents.
  • There has been no evidence submitted, nor is it stated in the Comprehensive Plans, that that an increase in the number and size of RV parks are recognizes as a desired outcome.
  • Brown County State Park does support camping to include RV Parks, Camping Trailers and Tent Camping. Covid has increased the demand for sites that may be addressed in the future by the Park. Over 50% of the land in Brown County is owned by the state, feds, or non-profit conservation organizations. Land Use for agriculture, residents and appropriate development that serves ALL residents are included in goals in the Comprehensive Plan.

03. Traffic and Safety

  • Brown County’s two-lane roads adds a constraint to increases in more visitors. Hard Truth Hills and the Music Center now contribute to more year-round tourism which adds more congestion to our roads.
  • The location of the proposed 185 Site RV Park is in close proximity to the intersection of old 46, Highway 46 and the North Gate Entrance to Brown County State Park. This intersection has been known to be among the most congested (and accident prone) in the county at times. The State has refused to put in a stop light. And, if they did put in a light, this would add to the back-up traffic on 46 creating more frustration and adding increased travel time for residents.

Indiana Citizen’s Planner’s Guide. Part 2 Board of Zoning Appeals Basics by KK Gerhart-Fritz, AICP, identifies “Developmental Standards Variance Criteria per IC 36-7-4-918.5”. Specifically:

01. The approval will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals, and general welfare of the community.

    • As stated above, the project is incompatible with the intent and goals expressed in the County Comprehensive Plan and the “Voice” of the residents.
    • Facebook comments from county specific Facebook groups (see enclosures) do identify residents’ concerns and opposition to this project. The public sentiment as well as the comprehensive plan, would likely support affordable housing for residents in this area.
    • The location of the proposed park does add to traffic congestion and risks to safety. The State may not approve a request for a traffic light and even if they did, this would add to traffic backups and impatient drivers that tend to create condition that may lead to more accidents

02. The use and value of the area adjacent to the property included in the variance will not be affected in a substantially adverse.

  • Adding a commercial property in an area consisting of agriculture and homes does have an adverse impact on the “natural beauty and rural atmosphere” as well as morale, that is intended to be protected by the Comprehensive Plan. Further, it sets a bad precedent.

03.The strict application of the terms of the zoning ordinance will result in practical difficulties in the use of the property.

  • “Practical difficulty” is adding to the congestion on Old 46 and 46 across from the North Gate to the State Park which will be the main ingress and regress routes. Traffic on old 46 will also be impeded. Luxury RV’s heading west on old 46 to Nashville would certainly add to the traffic congestion.

In conclusion, in addition to this planning guidance, the County Comprehensive Plan represents the “voice” of residents regarding their support for changes. The Facebook comments (see enclosures) provide a strong indication that a 185 Site RV Park is not acceptable.

Respectively,

Tim J. Clark

Enclosures

References:

Indiana Code 36-7-4-603 “Sec. 603. In preparing and considering proposals under the 600 series, the plan commission and the legislative body shall pay reasonable regard to:
  • (1) the comprehensive plan;
  • (2)  current conditions and the character of current structures and uses in each district;
  • (3) the most desirable use for which the land in each district is adapted;
  • (4) the conservation of property values throughout the jurisdiction; and
  • (5) responsible development and growth.”
 

Southern Indiana World-Wide Freedom Rally Nov. 20, 2021

Rally 2a dont tread

VIDEO:  Southern Indiana World-Wide Freedom Rally Nov. 20, 2021.  Video promoting the Brown County rally along with a video of likely the largest, first, grass-roots, peaceful, worldwide rally promoting human rights. The rallys were held in 100 cities in 40 countries.

Brown County Freedom Rally

Rally Organizers:   Brown County Indiana 2nd Amendment Freedom Fighters (Facebook –  Private Group)

Dont Tread on Indiana. Don’t Tread On Indiana is the advocacy arm of the Brown County Indiana Second Amendment Freedom Fighters, a grassroots coalition of like-minded Hoosiers, first organized on February 2, 2020, working together to help preserve and protect our great American values, customs and traditions. We are men and women from the great state of Indiana who revere God above the State, who firmly honor and support the US Constitution as the law of the land. To us the Bill of Rights is sacrosanct, and any attempts to infringe upon it are fundamentally unlawful, therefore unacceptable, and must be rebuked and defeated.

Don’t Tread On Indiana was formed to advocate for the legacy of the Founders, and to combat the encroachment of governmental overreach, socialistic propaganda and cultural subjugation — wherever we find it.

State Weekly Covid Reports, Trends, Treatment Options

risk management

Updated Feb 24, 2022  

 

Interntional – Policies

  • Stephen Moore: With few if any restrictions, COVID death rate in nation (SWEDEN) was lower than U.K., U.S. By Stephen Moore. Feb 23, 2022
    • Guided by The Great Barrington Declaration
    • Hail to the Swedes – they did it right
    • Two years later, Sweden’s COVID-19 death rate is 1,614 per million people – much lower than Britain (2,335) or the U.S. (2,836), which both had much more stringent lockdowns.

      Sweden appears to have achieved herd immunity much more swiftly and thoroughly than other nations. Deaths were higher at the start of the pandemic but fell much lower than other lockdown nations in succeeding months.

      What is clear today is that the Swedes saved their economy. This year, it’s projected to be 5% larger than before the pandemic, compared to a 2% gain for Germany and a 1% gain for Britain. Moreover, the extra debt Sweden has had to take on is a fraction of that of lockdown countries. So it will not have to spend decades paying for the costs of lockdowns.

      Swedish schools stayed open with no face masks.

Warning

Feb 19, 2022, “Everyone is at Risk for Blood Clots!” – CDC and Pfizer Issue Urgent Warnings on Blood Clots Even in “The Healthiest AthletesBy Jim Hoft Published February 19, 2022 at 7:45am

Early detection and treatment (within 72 hours) is critical – Dr. McCullough. In addition to the vaccination options, list of Covid Treatment Options using available drugs and vitamins

 

Brown County Indiana COVID-19 Vaccinations & Testing

Vaccinations by appointment only: Monday through Friday, 1 to 3:20 pm. To schedule an appointment for the COVID vaccination, visit ourshot.in.gov or call 211.

Testing by appointment only: Monday through Friday, 9 to 11:45 am. To schedule an appointment for testing, visit scheduling.coronavirus.IN.gov or call 211.

Key Points

  • Vaccinations do not provide immunity nor prevent transmission. They may lessen the severity of the symptoms.  Other available drugs may lessen symptons as well. 
  • Per CDC, 95% of deaths included a co-morbidity; 75% had four co-morbidities.
    • Dr. Peter McCullough: “Vaccines are largely unnecessary and if there was a safe and effective vaccine – if … the only application, in my view, would be our high-risk seniors, those in nursing homes, congregate living centers. Potentially, direct health care workers for our seniors. That’s it,” he said. “In the United States, that’s fewer than 3 million people would ever get a vaccine. I think we’ve seen the end of a broad employment of vaccines. It’s obviously backfired. Vaccination should only be narrow and targeted for highest risk group.”
  • The PCR test can produce false positives and is no longer recommended by the CDC;  On deaths, it is unknown how many people died “With” Covid as opposed to “From “ Covid.
  • The strategic focus has been on the “number of cases” – not on: (1) The protection of the most vulnerable, (2) The survivability rates by groups – near 100% in the younger and healthier citizens,  (3) Available treatments for the unvaccinated that lead to natural immunity, (4) Adverse effects in the near, mid and long-term.
  • Focused Protection was advocated by the signers  of the Great Barrington Declaration (Oct 4, 2020). Florida adopted this strategy which protects high-risk individuals and supports vaccinations that were made available beginnning Dec 14, 2020 (Wikipedia). Florida also supports treatments for the unvaccinated. The strategy does not include mandates or shutdowns.   

Summary
Updated Jan 24, 2022

National, State and Local Covid policies can be improved. Should the intent of policies be  that 100% of people survive the virus and its variants with no adverse effects?  What can be done to “prevent” infections? Adverse effects would include negative impacts in areas that include: medical (physical and mental health), economic, political, social, and cultural.   
 
    • El – Salvador – ad campaign to help prevent deaths and hospitalizations.Where the eff is our American medical establishment producing content like this? HHS, FDA, CDC?”  pic.twitter.com/XUTMkQF097 – — Benny (@bennyjohnson) January 5, 2022

An optimal strategy would support the pursuit of “Truth” e.g., the right answers. This would include breaking -down the issues, prioritize, and provide a variety of solutions. What individuals and groups are at the most risk?  Who are at the least risk?  What data is needed to assess progress?  This would include listening to those experts that challenge the prevailing narratives.

Polices that divide people (mandates for example) are always suboptimal, as is canceling and censoring experts that challenge the prevailing narrative. On the number of cases, this is an output measure – not outcome. Positive outcome indicators would include no deaths and no adverse effects. 

At a national level,  what was the process for approving a vaccine and monitoring its efficacy? What is the criteria for concluding that vaccines are not meeting requirements ? On approving the Covid vaccinations, what were the deviations from past practices and their associated risks and mitigation factors? Why is VAERS data ignored? Information in VAERS provides a leading indicator that effects may be leading to a systemic increase in mortality rates in some categories. One life insurance company has already reported an unexpected and unprecedented level of deaths. Will this be a trend?  

Bottom Line – From a quality management perspective, I would not give Indiana an “Incomplete.”  I would give Florida a B.  An “A” grade would include criteria that citizens have trust and confidence in policies and are provided the information that they need to assess that the policies are working – that the government is doing everything they can to support individual decision making. The politization of the issues undermines credibility and trust.  
 
 
Politics
 
 

Transparency

Stop the Mandate Rally.  Dr. Malone mentioned that half the doctors that spoke at the rally identified as Democrats.  A truly non-partisan pushback on national Covid policies.

    •  

Jan 24, 2022 Senate Hearing – Ron Johnson. COVID-19

    • A Second Opinion. Discussion begins around 40 minute mark. Sen. Ron Johnson moderates a panel discussion,  A group of world renowned doctors and medical experts provide a different perspective on the global pandemic response, the current state of knowledge of early and hospital treatment, vaccine efficacy and safety, what went right, what went wrong, what should be done now, and what needs to be addressed long term.
      More at www.ronjohnson.senate.gov

National Policies – Actions and Reactions

 
    • The U.S. medical strategy has focused almost exclusively on vaccines. A relentless stream of “breakthrough” infections, new safety concerns, and the continual emergence of new mutations suggest that doubling down on failing strategies not only leads to public frustration. It also inhibits us from exploring alternatives. Doing more of the same in the face of the omicron crisis does not evoke confidence or gain the public’s trust.  
    • We must reinvigorate new science that explores all evidence-based pathways to immunity. Natural infection and traditional vaccines, such as inactivated/dead virus, should be properly compared to mRNA and recombinant vaccines; the unvaccinated provide a much-needed control group in this regard. We also need a realistic testing plan that uses measures properly vetted by the regulatory agencies and provide standardized testing protocols globally. Celebrating progress is important. But let’s not celebrate our way to complacency. Evolving problems require creative new thinking. 

Dr. Malone, Peter Navarro publish ‘declaration of independence’ from vax mandates, ‘Frantic madness’ violates ‘every scientific principle we know’ by Art Moore, WND, Jan 14, 2022

    • Malone and Navarro warn, based on basic principles of virology, that universal vaccination could produce a “doomsday scenario.” … “The more you vaccinate, the more likely you will spawn vaccine-resistant mutations; and the more likely those vaccinated will fall prey to the mutations,” they write.

Fauci Says We’re Just In Phase One Of ‘Five Phases Of The Pandemic’ — Then Issues a Chilling Warning, 

What are the mid to long-term risks associated with the vaccines and boosters?

  • Tests. As of Dec 31, 2021, CDC is phasing out the PCR test for more accurate options. “CDC encourages laboratories to consider adoption of a multiplexed method that can facilitate detection and differentiation of SARS-CoV-2 and influenza viruses.”
    • Indiana. As of Jan 6, 2021. Rapid antigen tests are only available at some locations for anyone age 18 and younger and symptomatic individuals age 50 and older due to the limited supply. PCR tests with results in two or three days are available for everyone, regardless of age or symptoms.

Deaths Co-Morbidities. Per CDC, Covid identifed as the underlying cause of death listed on the death certificate.  There were co-morbidities or other conditions listed on the death certificate for as many as 95% of all Covid deaths. Obesity worsens outcomes from Covid-19.

comorbidities covid jan 2 2022

CDC Director: Over 75% Of COVID Deaths In Vaccinated Had ‘At Least 4 Comorbidities’ By Hank Berrien,     DailyWire.com

Hospitalizations – “For” Covid or with other conditions “with” Covid?  “In NYC, 49% of people hospitalized were admitted for COVID, everyone else just happened to test positive” -e.g. “with” Covid. 

Covid Policy – A suggested Course of Action (Solution). The Great Barrington Declaration– “The single document that will go down as one of the most important publications in the pandemic” – Dr. Scott Atlas, American physician and healthcare policy expert, Former White House Coronavirus Response team member. Barrington Policy adopted by Sweden and Florida.

    • Has the Great Barrington Declaration been vindicated? Lockdowns failed to serve the collective good BY  AND Jan 10, 2022
      • Their psychological, social and economic impact might have been justified from a collective-interest and life-saving standpoint if Covid represented an equal threat to all citizens. 
      • it became clear that Covid-19 was almost exclusively a threat to the elderly (60+): in the last quarter of 2020, the mean age of those dying both with and of Covid-19 in the UK was 82.4, while by early 2020 the Infection Fatality Rate (IFR) — the risk of actually dying if you catch Covid — in people under 60 was already known to be exceptionally low: 0.5 per cent or less. A paper written late in 2020 for the WHO by professor John Ioannidis of Stanford University, one of the world’s foremost epidemiologists, then estimated that the IFR for those under 70 was even lower: 0.05%. As Woolhouse points out in his interview “people over 75 are an astonishing 10,000 times more at risk than those who are under 15”.
      • In early 2021, John Ioannidis published a paper claiming that there was no practical difference in epidemiological terms between countries that had locked down and those that hadn’t. Several other studies have appeared since then that confirm Ioannidis’s initial findings: see, for example, herehere and here
      • According to a recent Collateral Global study, Covid deaths in nursing homes amount on average to a staggering 40% of all Covid deaths in Western countries, despite representing less than 1% of the population.
      • In view of this, it seems obvious that the focused protection approach championed by the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) — based on “allow[ing] those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk” — was the right course of action. 

      • Lockdowns had little or no impact on COVID-19 deaths, new study shows, Washington Time. Jan 31, 2022. 

        • Lockdowns in the U.S. and Europe had little or no impact in reducing deaths from COVID-19, according to a new analysis by researchers at Johns Hopkins University.

        • “We find no evidence that lockdowns, school closures, border closures, and limiting gatherings have had a noticeable effect on COVID-19 mortality,” the researchers wrote.

        • But the research paper said lockdowns did have “devastating effects” on the economy and contributed to numerous social ills. “They have contributed to reducing economic activity, raising unemployment, reducing schooling, causing political unrest, contributing to domestic violence, and undermining liberal democracy,” the report said.

           

Florida Surgeon General – Joseph Ladapo.   “Vaccines are available. Treatments are available,”  “If you do get COVID, get treated early.” Ladapo argued doctors haven’t made enough effort on the treatment side: “The other component that other states should adopt is both preventative and treatment. Makes me sad as a scientist and a doctor that more effort is not made to connect patients with treatments. That has cost many lives during the pandemic.”
    • “To Ladapo, being the “anti-Fauci” means “being considerate of the fact that health means more than avoiding a virus. It’s been a terrible time with social isolation, loneliness. What we’ve done to children has been criminal, disconnecting them from their peers and disrupting their education even though they’ve always been at low risk. There are multiple components of health.”
    • Florida Covid Stats.  As of Jan 26, 2022  Survival Rate Estimate 98.82%. 
    • Florida – Covid Reports

RCP Coronavirus Tracker, Coronavirus (COVID-19) U.S. Deaths

USAFacts.org: US COVID-19 cases and deaths by state

A recent headline in the IndyStar:  Indiana in last place on list of ‘Safest States During COVID-19’Rashika Jaipuriar, Indianapolis Star, Dec 18, 2021.

    • Reinforces how statistics can be used to sell a false narrative. Indiana is “last on list of safest states”? They (WalletHub) list the states with the lowest death rates as Alabama, Florida, DC, Alaska, Louisiana. These states have a combined median Survival Estimate Rate of 98.31%. Indiana’s median rate (Oct 6-Dec 16) is 98.44%. This is the percent of people that test positive and live.  Ref: USAFacts.org

safest states covid

Indiana COVID-19 Data Report. The SO WHAT?  Should the purpose of a “Report” also be to provide feedback to citizens as to what is working and what is not in response to Covid? Should this include identifying  prevention measures, the types of treatments available and provided, estimated risks to citizens on  vaccinations injuries as listed/identified in VAERS and other government sources) to citizens? 

    • Isn’t the “ideal”  solutions that are 100% effective without any side effects?  This would require forums where scientific-based challenges to the prevailing narrative are welcome and would support the need for additional studies, data and analysis in making progress towards the ideal.
    • Quality of the Data.  Indiana’s Attorney General recently challenged  the quality of the Covid related data being reported by the State.
      • Indiana governor accuses AG of fanning the flames of confusion of COVID-19, By Margaret Menge | The Center Square contributor, Dec 30, 2021.

        • Rokita’s office provided a statement from the attorney general: “A lack of global standardization of the data and non-uniform use of criteria is an industry-wide management issue, not an Inspector General issue.”  

        • “Dr. Lindsay Weaver, who said the state Department of Health had reviewed the VAERS data for Indiana and did not see any issues.”
          • How was this conclusion determined?
      • Indiana AG defends saying COVID-19 numbers can’t be trusted By Margaret Menge | The Center Square contributor, Jan 10, 2022.
        • “Hoosiers deserve transparency in reporting of Covid data so they can make their own medical decisions.” 
        • “he went on to say the omicron variant is “a much milder variant” and the focus should be on deaths, not on the number of cases.”
      • What’s the definition of “fully-vaccinated”?  Is a patient who received the vaccination considered “unvaccinated” until fifteen days have passed since the second jab?  When do the most severe reactions to the vax occur?   
      • CDC Manipulated Studies In Order to Prop Up Official COVID Narrative. By Dr. Joseph Mercola.  Two studies published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — both of questionable quality — allow the agency to claim COVID vaccines are safer and more effective than they really are. 

    • Alberta Canada Inadvertently Published (and Quickly Deleted) Health Data Exposing that MORE THAN HALF of VACCINATED DEATHS Have Been COUNTED AS UNVACCINATED By Julian Conradson Published January 23, 2022 at 3:00p

      • According to its latest Covid-19 update, the Alberta Government admitted to following the fraudulent standard that was in use by vaccine manufacturers during clinical trials – which is to ignore the adverse outcomes, including Covid infection, hospitalizations, and deaths, for fourteen days after vaccine administration – no matter how many doses they have had.

Questions on Data Quality

      • What is the variation in how  positive cases and deaths are tallied?   Why are the adverse effects from the vaccines  underreported in VAERS?  What is the accuracy rate of the various tests?   
      • Operational Definitions are critical in providing some assurance regarding the quality of the information being reported. 
      •  “Indiana life insurance CEO says deaths are up 40% among people ages 18-64”.  By Margaret Menge,  The Center Square, Jan 1, 2022  and follow-on articles.

Questions – Indiana Covid Policy

    • Omnicron: How likely is Omicron to deliver not an irritating cold but the worst flu of your life? How does that risk increase with the number and severity of medical conditions a person has? What are the chances of lingering symptoms following a mild illness? How long does immunity last after a booster shot or an infection?Ref: The New Yorker. What is the effect on those with natural immunity?
    • Not shown in the State reports or provided is the additional number and percent of citizens that recovered from Covid and have natural immunity.
    • Adverse Effects.  What are the known side-effects from the vaccines?  What are the know side-effects from those that were unvaxxed but recovered, e.g., such as no sense of smell or taste? 
    • What are the adverse effects from the vaccine reported in VAERS?  What percent of adverse reactions are reported in Indiana?
    • On “New Positive Cases,” how many were vaccinated vs unvaccinated. Of those that were vaccinated and contracted a new variant, what are the treatment protocols? For the unvaccinated with or without natural immunity, what are the recommended treatment protocols?   
    • Of the deaths, how many of these were individuals with comorbidities? What were the ages? How many were vaccinated vs unvaccinated? For the unvaccinated, how many had natural immunity?
      • Answer : The CDC Reports that there were co-morbidities or other conditions listed on the death certificate for as many as 95% of all Covid deaths. Obesity worsens outcomes from Covid-19. CDC Director states over 75% of  COVID Deaths In Vaccinated Had ‘At Least 4 Comorbidities’
    • Does the state (or “county health department”) support supplementing your diet with Vitamin D, C, and Zinc? Other recommendations?  Is there correlation to mortality and obesity?
    • Does the current reporting infer that ALL citizens should be vaccinated? If so, this is most likely an unrealistic goal and does not provide the quality of information citizens need to make informed decisions on vaccinations. Individuals throughout the country are leaving their jobs when given the ultimatum to get vaccinated.

Available Treatments?  The supported treatments in Indiana for the unvaccinated that contract Covid is the Monoclonal Antibody Therapy – funded by the Feds. This option has recently been “paused” by the federal government.  Why would you take this option off the table?  How many states (other than Florida), will step-up to fund this treatment?

Treatment Options for Individuals.  “Early Detection and Treatment (within 72 hours) helps to  prevent  hospitalizationDr. Peter McCullough
 

 Veritas Documents Reveal DC Bureaucrats Had Evidence Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine Were Effective in Treating COVID — BUT HID THIS FROM PUBLIC By Jim Hoft

 
Covid Survival Rate – Weekly Data Provided by the State of Indiana

 

 Should the expectation be that the Survival Rate is 100%?  

Estimate – Infection Mortality Rate (IFR):  Deaths divided Positive cases times 100.

Estimate – Survival Rate (positive cases – deaths) / positive cases x 100.

Infection Fatality Rate (IFR) world wide – Dr. John Ioannidis,  Stanford University  The infection fatality rate (IFR), the probability of dying for a person who is infected, is  one of the most critical and most contested features of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. The expected total mortality burden of COVID-19 is directly related to the IFR. Moreover, justification for various non-pharmacological public health interventions depends crucially on the IFR. Some aggressive interventions that potentially induce also more pronounced collateral harms may be considered appropriate, if IFR is high. Conversely, the same measures may fall short of acceptable risk-benefit thresholds, if the IFR is low.  “Extrapolating from confirmed cases, he (Dr. Ioannidis) concluded that, around the world, more than half a billion people have probably been infected with COVID. Using that metric, Dr. Ioannidis concluded that most locations around the world have an IFR that’s less than 0.20%.  

  • IFR Dr. Ioannidis Stanford Infection Survival Rate IFR covid
 

State Percentages – Estimated Survival Rate – Is the inferred goal a 100% survival rate?
(Note: (11/29/21) Statistical significance can be derived from a calculation. Significance by itself is subjective.  I did not calculate “statistical significance.” I leave this up to the statisticians. 


          (Positive Cases/Deaths)

    • 10/6/2021: 98.47%;
    • 10/13/2021: 98.44%
    • 10/21/2021: 98.42%
    • 10/27/2021: 98.41%
    • 11/4/2021: 98.41%
    • 11/11/2021: 98.43%
    • 11/17/2021: 98.44%  
    • 11/23/2021: 98.45%
    • 12/8/2021: 98.47%
    • 12/16/2021: 98.50%
    • 12/21/2021: 98.50%
    • 1/2/2022: 98.56%
    • 1/6/2022: 98.57% “RED”
    • 1/13/2022: 98.63% “RED”
    • 1/19/2022: 98.68% “RED”  Upward ‘Trend”
    • 1/26/2022: 98.72% “RED” Slight upward increase
    • 2/3/2022: 98.72% RED 
    • 2/9/2022: 98.82%
    • Median: 98.49%

run chart covid 1 feb 9 2022

In addition to a run chart (see interpretation rules below), the application of a few more basic tools of quality would be helpful. In addition to baseline data, what is not typically provided is the stratification of cases that would include country, age, gender, level of fitness, co-morbidities, preventive measures taken, treatment protocols, et.al  This would provide the data needed to offer a range of successful options.
 
Cause-effect diagrams and Pareto charts are also helpful tools in identifying improvement opportunities.
 
Also missing in the discussion are the system diagrams that identify the “end-to-end” process – from vaccine development, approval, and deployment through eradication.  Documentation of the end-to-end process also applies to the other treatment options using available drugs. This would help identify the data needed throughout the process to compare the “ideal” – solutions that are 100% effective without any side effects, with the actual situation. This would require forums where scientific-based challenges to the narrative are welcome and would support the need for additional studies, data and analysis in making progress towards the ideal.
 
Cases going up, down, staying about the same?
  • Trends – Increases? Decreases?  Systemic Changes?
    • The most common misuse of statistics is when based on the numbers, a judgment is made that something is increasing or decreasing. What is generally unknown is that there are standards pioneered in America and accepted internationally for identifying  trends.

      Generally, you need 20-25 data points that can then be placed on a Run Chart along with the median (center-line). Depending on the standard, the following trends would indicate an increase or decrease and if it was sustained, would indicate a systemic change: Six (6) consecutive points in a row rising or falling; Eight (8) consecutive points in a row above or below the centerline. The simplest standard is the Rule of 7 – 7 data points in a row increasing or decreasing or 7 in a row above or below the centerline. (PQ Systems Trends)

Feb 9, 2022BCM Facebook Post. State Weekly Covid Report as of Feb 9, 2022. Covid Recovry Rate (Name change from “Survival Rate Estimate”: 98.82% (upward trend).   Shouldn’t the goal be that 100% of people survive the virus and its variants with no adverse effects?  If so, how are we doing on that?

Feb 3, 2022. BCM Facebook Post.  Survival Rate Estimate: 98.72% (upward trend).   Shouldn’t the goal be that 100% of people survive the virus and its variants with no adverse effects?  If so, whow are doing on that?

Jan 26, 2022.  BCM Facebook Post.  State Weekly Covid Report as of Jan 26, 2022. Survival Rate Estimate: 98.72% (upward trend).   Shouldn’t the goal be that 100% of people survive the virus and its variants with no adverse effects?  If so, whow are doing on that? Per BCD, total deaths for Brown County is 58 (up 2). The percentage of residents who are now partially vaccinated remains at 57.

(Positive cases: 1,604, 072; Total Deaths: 20, 508). Per BCD, total deaths for Brown County is 58 ( (up 7). Partially vaccinated rate at 57%.

Jan 19, 2022BCM Facebook Post.  State Weekly Covid Report as of Jan 19, 2022. Survival Rate Estimate: 98.68% (upward trend).   Shouldn’t the goal be that 100% of people survive the virus and its variants with no adverse effects?  Per BCD, total deaths for Brown County is 56 (up 2). The percentage of residents who are now partially vaccinated is 57 percent (no change from last week). 

Jan 13 , 2022. BCM Facebook Post

State Weekly Covid Report as of Jan 13, 2022. Survival Rate Estimate: 98.63% (Positive cases: 1,425, 877; Total Deaths: 19,491). Per BCD, total deaths for Brown County is 54 (up 3). The percentage of residents who are now partially vaccinated is now 57 percent.  The CDC Reports that there were co-morbidities or other conditions listed on the death certificate for as many as 95% of all Covid deaths. Obesity worsens outcomes from Covid-19. 

CDC Director: Over 75% Of COVID Deaths In Vaccinated Had ‘At Least 4 Comorbidities

Jan 6, 2022. BCM Facebook Post

Survival Rate Estimate: 98.57% (Positive cases: 1,329, 423; Total Deaths: 18,959). Total deaths for Brown County is 51.

Jan 4, 2022. BCD, State warns of ‘very steep rise’ in COVID-19 cases By  Staff Reports

Per CDC, There were co-morbidities or other conditions listed on the death certificate for as many as 95% of all Covid deaths. Obesity worsens outcomes from Covid-19.

Jan 2, 2022 BCM Facebook Post

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.56% (Positive cases: 1,278, 285; Total Deaths: 18,433).   
  •  

Dec 21, 2021BCM Facebook Post

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.50% (Positive cases: 1,200, 926; Total Deaths: 18,057).   
  • Note: Per ISDH, the dashboard will not update Thursday 12/23 through Sunday 12/26. Normal updates will resume on Monday, 12/27.

 Dec 17, 2021 – BCM Facebook Post

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.50% (Positive cases: 1,181,554; Total Deaths: 17,757).   
  • Brown County Survival Rate Estimate:  97.35% (Positive cases 1,886; Deaths 50).
  • County vaccination rate: 56% (up 1%)

Dec 8, 2021. BCM Facebook Post

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.47% (Positive cases: 1,145,633; Total Deaths: 17,351).  The percentage of the Brown County is  55 percent.  
  • NEW. Brown County Survival Estimate Rate:  97.3% (Positive cases 1,826; Deaths 50).
  • County vaccination rate: 55%

Nov 17-23, 2021.

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.45% (Positive cases: 1,084,488; Total Deaths: 16, 805).  The percentage of the Brown County is  54 percent. No statistically signficant change over the past 7 weeks.
  • NEW. Brown County Survival Estimate Rate:  97.1% (Positive cases 1,697; Deaths 50).

Nov 17, 2021.

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.44% (Positive cases: 1,069,450; Total Deaths: 16, 673).  The percentage of those who are partially vaccinated as of Nov. 17 is now 54 percent. No statistically signficant change over the past 6 weeks.

Nov 11, 2021.

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.43% (Positive cases: 1,047,847; Total Deaths: 16, 447). County vaccination rate is 53%.   No statistically signficant change over the past 5 weeks.

Nov 4, 2021

  • Survival Rate Estimate: 98.41% (Positive cases: 1,030,291; Total Deaths: 16, 336). County vaccination rate is 53%.   No statistically signficant change over the past month. 

Oct  27, 2021

  • Estimated Survival Rate:  98.41% (Positive cases: 1,016,722; Total Deaths: 16,117)
  • IFR:  1.59%
 

Oct 21, 2021.

    • Survival Rate:  98.42% (Positive cases:  1,007, 681; Total Deaths: 15,930)
    • Using the recent population data from the 2020 Census, which shows the county’s population to be 15,475, the percentage of those who are partially vaccinated dropped to around 52 percent.
    • FB Post – BCM
    • FB Post – BCD

Oct 13, 2021. 98.44% (Deaths 15, 694), Total Positive Cases 994,079). Brown County vaccination percentage remains around 53 percent.

Oct 6, 202198.47%. (Deaths 15,442) compared to Total Positive Cases (979,000). Brown County vaccination percentage remains around 53 percent.

Additional Information

  •  

ASQ Testing Efficiency and Effectiveness of Government

ANSI G1 – A New Baseline for Testing Efficiency and Effectiveness of Government

In March 2021, the American National Standards Institute published a new professional standard to define the efficiency and effectiveness of government operations, ASQ/ANSI: G1 2021. One of the principal authors of this new standard, Richard Mallory, provides an overview of what it is, how it can be used, and why it is destined to be the primary focus of quality practices in government in the future.

Brown County IN – County And Community Capability Maturity And Potential

Data Interpretation Standards and Tools

The most common misuse of statistics is when based on the numbers, a judgment is made that something is increasing or decreasing. What is generally unknown is that there are standards pioneered in America and accepted internationally for assessing trends.

Generally, you need 20-25 data points that can then be placed on a run chart along with the median (center-line). Depending on the standard, the following criteria would indicate an increase or decrease and if it was sustained, might indicate a systemic change:

    • Six (6) Consecutive Points in a row rising or falling;
    • Eight (8) Consecutive Points in a row above or below the centerline.
    • The simplest standard is the rule of 7 – 7 data points in a row increasing or decreasing or 7 in a row above or below the centerline. (PQ Systems Trends)

Background Info – overview of quality management concepts, principles, methods and tools – Success through Quality

Another crtical concept in Quality Management is Operational Definitions.

LinkedIn – Covid – Misuse of Control Charts by Dr. Tony Burns Misuse of Process Behavior Charts is rife. An example of such misuse is the many attempts to use Process Behavior Charts for Covid data.
    • Down the Rabbit Hole have shown how the right approach is Professor Deming’s “Operational Definition”, or what Dr Shewhart called “Operational Meaning”:
    1. What do you want to accomplish?
    2.  By what method will you accomplish your objective?
    3.  How will you know when you have accomplished your objective?
    • The first step is to ask, what are you trying to achieve? Professor Deming wanted to know if the processes he was studying were running at their maximum potential. He also asked whether these processes would continue to run at their maximum potential into the future. The tool he chose was the Shewhart Chart.
    • The first step with Covid data should be to ask “What do you want to accomplish?” Folk trying to draw control charts for Covid data have not asked this question.
    • What we want to know about Covid is whether it is getting better or worse. What we want to accomplish is a downward trend. The best method to observe such trends is the Run Chart, or Bar Chart.
    • Control Charts cannot help answer this question. All that a control chart can show is that the data is non-homogeneous. However we already know this because of the way the disease is spread from one person to many more people.
    • Control charts are ideal for bringing a process to its full potential and ensuring good quality into the future. They are worthless for COVID-19 data. Use a run/bar chart as shown. Run charts are ideal for showing trends.
    • “How will you know when you have accomplished your objective?” We will know this when the Run Chart trends to zero.
    • The root cause for the ubiquitous misuse of Process Behavior Charts is firstly courses failing to teach the fundamentals of Quality. The second cause is statistical software which encourages the blind pressing of buttons without thinking. When you have bought an expensive hammer, don’t spend your time looking for things to use it on. Use common sense instead.  THINK.

KEEP IT SIMPLE

    • “But, as we have seen, an epidemic is anything but a steady-state system. It grows, changes, and evolves. We do not need to ask the question “Has a change occurred?” because we know that by its very nature every epidemic is constantly changing. This is why any attempt to use a process behavior chart to analyze the daily Covid values is a misapplication of the technique. It is conceptually equivalent to someone computing the average for a list of telephone numbers.” – Dr Wheeler.
    • www.q-skills.com