Andy Rogers: Vision for Brown County and Nashville

city vs tourist

Sep 17,  2019. BCD, Change coming to Andy Rogers’ neighborhood By Sara Clifford.

  • For 67 years, some member of Liana Franklin’s family has been unlocking the door of The Totem Post, visiting with customers for hours, and sending them off with a treasure, or at least a memory.
  • Same story next door at the Jack & Jill Nut Shoppe with Marc Rudd’s family, for 50 years now.
  • On one day in October, at least eight vacant parcels and eight buildings in Nashville — including the homes of 25 downtown shops — will go on the auction block.
  • In terms of number of properties, it’s likely to be the largest real estate transfer in the history of Nashville.
  • The properties are part of the estate of Frank “Andy” Rogers, who was a bedrock of Nashville’s business community.

 Brown County loses Andy Rogers.  Andy Rogers passed away July 19, 2018. His vision for accommodating tourism and not destroying the culture and “soul” of the county is being seriously challenged by the few that may want to exploit more tourism focused development.

“People say, ‘Well, we can’t change.’ But we can change and still retain some of the flavor of Brown County. We need people to live here. I’m in the tourist business but we don’t want to turn this town over to the tourists. You can go to Gatlinburg if you want to see what happens to a town that turns it all over to business. It’s not a town anymore—it’s a shopping center. We need people here. This town needs to be alive.” 

“We don’t need to be slick and highly commercial. We need to be more country. Country is what we sell…. We need to maintain that. Once you destroy that, it won’t come back.”

‘Andy’s always been there’  BCD, Suzanna Couch

  • “Don’t forget that through the years, we have grown in population, and we also have grown in what people’s needs and wants are. 
  • It is all about respect. “Respect them and their abilities — or lack of them — to get along,” he said. “They contribute. They have to. But you have to have respect for them.”

Brown County Memories – Andy Rogers Recalls, by Bill Weaver, Our Brown County

  • “He stands at the center of Nashville’s dogged attempt to satisfy a tourist industry while retaining its soul—the thing that people have lost in their own communities, the reason they come to visit in the first place. 
  •  So you can imagine my surprise when I discover that Rogers was not born in Brown County.”
A Competing Vision for Tourism

 Will this new vision retain and attract residents or will it result in Brown County being considered a fun place to visit but not to live?    

My Guest Column in the Democrat: A study of tourism and economic sustainability  Provides context regarding tourism-related jobs and wages. Note: The proponents of the government-owned Maple Leaf music venue project claimed that Maple Leaf “….  could be what it takes to turn things around economically for Brown County.”  This article was written to offer another perspective.  The county is funded primarily by income and property tax.  

The Brown County Community Readiness Initiative, a survey and economic assessment conducted by the Ball State Economic and Research Institute, concluded that Brown County’s greatest potential for economic growth is not tourism, but as a bedroom community – BC Democrat – Sara Clifford

Brown County:  Tourism: Facts, Assumptions, Myths – Tim Clark, Indep Voters

The Maple Leaf Effect? – “The little town that never sleeps?”

GUEST OPINION: ‘Coming together is a beginning  The Maple Leaf Effect? and Working toward ‘a more perfect union’   Excerpts – Future scenarios can include the following:

Best case is that MLPAC exceeds all expectations. A worse case is that the venue does not meet expectations, requiring a decision as to the disposition of an underperforming venue.  

  • County Council included the worst case being an economic crash and if this occurred, the venue would be turned over to the bank and the county would start  collecting property taxes on the venue.

1. Status quo plus. The additional increase in year-round tourism from Big Woods/Hard Truth Hills (destination distillery) and the Maple Leaf Performing Arts Center (MLPAC) are added to the tourism portfolio with some noticeable impacts on the culture of the county. This will include more events to promote entertainment, craft beer, wine and spirits tourism and additional traffic congestion. An increase in revenue from income and property taxes, the primary source of revenue for the county, might offset the increase in county infrastructure-related costs.

2. Transformative. The expectations for the MLPAC were identified as leading to an increase in year-round tourism that would result in an economic turnaround, more jobs, hotel(s) and restaurants. These changes could possibly include the transition of Snyder Farm as an extension of Salt Creek Plaza. The requirement to fill a 2,000-seat venue will likely lead to offering any entertainment option and attracting any demographic that will sell tickets and attract visitors. Shops in Nashville could transition to bars or other dining and entertainment options that will encourage visitors to stay longer and spend more money. Other areas along the State Road 46 corridor could transition to tourist-related businesses. A casino might fit into this scenario. Entertainment, craft beer, wine and spirits tourism become a major part of the Brown County “brand.” The cumulative effect of the changes may lead to Brown County being considered a nice place to visit but not to live.

3. Collaborative planning. Community conversations can help identify the best acceptable alternatives for tourism, community and economic development options. To quote Henry Ford, “Coming together is a beginning. Keeping together is progress. Working together is success.” Conversations can lead to strategies, strategies to plans, and good plans lead to results where everyone benefits — or at least accepts that a given initiative is beneficial overall. The collaborative approach can lead to the county being recognized as a “community of excellence,” which attracts more residents, businesses and families. An increase in families helps mitigate the decline in school enrollments and prevents school closures and consolidations.

3 thoughts on “Andy Rogers: Vision for Brown County and Nashville

  1. Thanks for posting my Dad Andy Rogers’s visions for Brown County and letting us not lose sight of them. There has to be a balance between the needs of the residents which are the base and tourism.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s