June 14, 2022. I attended the information meeting regarding the tentative/proposed referendum at the June 14, 2022, session. Copies of the handouts are provided below:
The last referendum was passed in 2016 by more than 1,000 votes or 59% of the vote. There was a strong campaign by the proponents of the tax including guest columns, Letters in the Democrat, and yard signs.
Who can vote?IC 20-46-1-16 Qualified voters Sec. 16. (a) The individuals entitled to vote in the referendum are all of the registered voters resident in the appellant school corporation. (b) An individual who changes residence from a location within a school corporation to a location outside of the school corporation less than thirty (30) days before an election under this chapter may not vote on the public question. [Pre-2006 Recodification Citation: 6-1.1-19-4.5(c) part.] As added by P.L.2-2006, SEC.169. Amended by P.L.109-2021, SEC.76.
Indiana – Education Policy – School Choice and Vouchers. Indiana is recognized as a school choice state. The Brown County school administration (the school board, former superintendents Hammack and Shaffer) have been against funding for vouchers that provide citizens with a choice for educating their children. In 2021, the budget bill containing the school voucher language and ESAs passed the House 96-2 and the Senate 46-3. (Ref: Indiana expands school voucher program to include most middle-class families, by Margaret Menge | The Center Square contributor, April 23, 2021._
Justification. The need to maintain or increase the revenue from a referendum appears to be the same as it was in 2016. By state law, the proposed increase must be based on need vs a want (a nice to have). Indiana Code 20-46-1-8 allows the governing body of a school corporation to adopt a resolution to place a public question on a ballot if the governing body determines that the school corporation …
cannot carry out its public educational duty unless it imposes a referendum tax levy or
that a referendum tax levy should be imposed to replace property tax revenue that the school corporation will not receive because of the application of circuit breaker credits.
Meeting this standard (see 1) implies a thorough analysis of alternatives. This would include the identification of the costs, benefits, risks, and the respective risk mitigation strategies. Put another way, what specifically will be the effects of not passing a new referendum?
The criteria used to make the decision should clearly reflect that the tax levy is a critical need for the school to carry outs its educational duty. Should a criterion include the inability to meet the guidelines from the state regarding student-teacher ratios?
Decision-makers. The voters decide on the quality of the analysis and the school’s proposal for a tax levy. “In the case of the school corporation’s determination to have a referendum, there is no statutory remonstrance opportunity that is separate from the referendum itself. Whether it succeeds or fails depends on the results of the vote.” – DLGF
Economic Situation. Unlike in 2016, the economic situation is a little different this time around. Record inflation, gas, and food prices. The stock market is experiencing significant losses affecting 401Ks and retirement income. Inflated home values and high demand for homes along with annual property assessments have resulted in yearly property tax increases for many if not most residents. The cost of utilities continues to increase. In 2017, a statistically valid survey identified that the county has a low to moderate-income level of 53.1%. This combined with many residents with fixed and declining incomes combined with social security not keeping pace with inflation, reinforces the obligation to validate that continuing a tax increase is the best option.
County Taxes. The county has one of the highest income tax rates in the state, doubled it in 10 years, has maxed it out, and has been relying on annual property tax increases and borrowing to fund the county government.
Continuing the tax vs taxes decreasing. The increase in revenue from the referendum is about a million a year. Typically, a selling point on renewing a tax is that it is about the same, or in this case, maybe it could be a little higher, e.g, residents will not see an “increase.” Seems every time a tax increase is proposed in the county, it is always followed by comments like “it’s just a few dollars or just pennies a day.”
National Issues. Covid policies and mandates and school shutdown policies may affect some voters’ desire to vote Yes to a tax increase. Associations and teacher unions supporting policies such as Critical Race Theory (CRT) may also undermine the support for public education in general.
National School Board Association (NSBA): ” Following the National School Boards Association letter sent to the White House comparing parents to domestic terrorists, the nation’s largest teachers union sent a letter to social media companies encouraging them to crack down on “propaganda” surrounding Critical Race Theory (CRT) and other education concerns raised by parents.” (1)
National Education Association (NEA). “Despite NEA claims that there are unfounded beliefs regarding “graduate level courses about racism,” in U.S. public schools, the union approved a plan to implement CRT in 14,000 school districts across all 50 states in July.” (1)
Four days after the NSBA letter was sent, Attorney General Merrick Garland issued a memorandum that called on the FBI to “use its authority” against parents who threaten or use violence against public school officials. (1)
Process and Due Diligence on behalf of all citizens. My interest as a citizen is in the decision-making process. Has the school corporation performed its due diligence? When was it identified that another referendum may be needed? Was this identified by the strategic plan? What actions were or have been taken? Does the analysis of alternatives support and justify the need?
Systemic Decline in Enrollment. The school has experienced a systemic decline in enrollment since about 2008/2009 and has successfully managed to do the more or same with less revenue. This includes applying for and receiving grants from a variety of sources that have led to improvements in the quality of education.
Population projections for the county indicate that the population peaked in 2020 and will continue to decline. Brown County has one of the older demographics in the State.
Demographics. Given demographic projections, what is the best case, worse, and the average case regarding enrollment over the next few years? What is the state guidance regarding student/teacher ratios? How many classrooms and teachers will be needed at the projected enrollment levels? Correspondingly, how much infrastructure (number of schools) will be needed?
In summary, the School, through an analysis of alternatives, need to make the case that the new tax levy is needed. Voters can assess the quality of the analysis in support of their respective decision.
o. Short meeting. I was 20 minutes late and the meeting was over. It was like Christmas. Commissioners selected the vendor for the paving contracts that cover 20 miles. An additional 10 miles is expected to be paved with the money from the Community Crossings Grant.
BCRSD (Brown County Regional Sewer District). Board members: Clint Studabaker, Mike Leggins, Phil LeBlanc, Richard Hall, Matt Hanlon
Public Presentation BCRSD Wastewater Strategy and Sep 2021 Watershed Study. Public presentation (will streamed) tentatively scheduled for Juy 18, 2022. Time to be determined. Available locations at which a representative of the board will be available for questions is at Helmsburg, Spunica, Van Buren schools.
What’s new?
The justification of need for expanding and forcing sewer service has been based on speculation regarding the lack of records for septic systems and age of homes. There is no specific documented evidence of failing systems. This has been confirmed by the two previous BCRSD Presidents. A well-designed and maintained septic system has an indefinite life per EPA and Presby.
Some of the water samples have indicated that “some” of the E.Coli is human-caused indicating a failing system. However, the number of systems that may be contributing to the problem was not identified. A large percentage of systems would justify the investment of tax money and support the scope of the wastewater strategic plan.
Note that the Proposed County Wastewater Plan was developed by “government appointees” – not elected officials. This plan is not aligned with the County Comprehensive Plan that does have to be approved by “elected” officials after holding the required public hearings.
No information has been provided regarding whether or not the plan and study would be pre-briefed to the Commissioners and Council at a public meeting.
Note also an RSD will not need the approval of elected officials to force their plan onto the citizenry. An RSD also has the power to invoke eminent domain that may be needed to get the required easements (estimated at 190 in the Bean Blossom area). However, without a valid need, residents may have a legal base to fight the granting of easements if so desired. Residents can also contract for their own water samples to validate findings.
Helmsburg – Lake Lemon. There is a valid and documented need for sewer service in the Lake Lemon Area and for upgrading the Helmsburg Plant.
Additional Information
Link to the Strategic Plan: I found the following statement in the Plan to be misleading: “The primary source of E.coli has been found to be from humans.” (Ref: Executive Overview, p vi). Per the watershed study, the primary source IN SOME SAMPLES has been found to be from humans.
The modeling information was interesting: ”Only if 100% of documented septic systems are failing do they contribute a significant volume of E. Coli to the entirety of Brown County.” (Ref: Watershed Study, p70)
The BCRSD still pushing the expansion of sewer service without an understanding of the scope and extent of the problem. No information was identified as to how many“systems” are failing to include what it could cost to mitigate. The Pareto Principle suggests that 80% of a problem (human-caused e-coli) could be from 20% of the causes (failing septic systems ).
If the BCRSD think they have the needed evidence (probable cause) of failing systems, then get a warrant from a Judge if needed to inspect the system (s) to confirm the assumptions. Residents could also voluntarily agree to an inspection of their system.
Water Management District (WMD). This would shift the responsibility to the county to manage individual septic systems – at a cost TBD.
The Fox host warned that we were at a turning point with the state “replacing” civil society.
“Life, Liberty & Levin” host Mark Levin ripped those in power for trying to take away individual liberties when tragedy strikes instead of evaluating their own policy failures.
On his Sunday night show, Levin illustrated how the “ruling class,” the government, the media, big tech companies and academia, routinely attack the rights of the individual in the First and Second Amendments, so they can grab more power for themselves
“I think a little bit more faith would help in the schools and in the public square,” Levin said. “It’s not such a terrible thing, and yet, we have secularized everything. I think a little bit more respect for the American people in the media rather than bringing on racists, some bigots who push their agenda. Couldn’t hurt.”
“I am the vine, you are the branches. He who abides in Me, and I in him, bears much fruit; for without Me you can do nothing.” – John 15:5.
Ken Ham: Your Worldview — If It’s Not Biblical, It’s Wrong! Why is church attendance decreasing SO drastically? In this presentation, Ken Ham discusses the mass exodus that churches are experiencing in Western society and what Christians can do about it.
Worldview – American Heritage Dictionary. The overall perspective from which one sees and interprets the world; A collection of beliefs about life and the universe held by an individual or a group. One’s personal view of the world and how one interprets it.
“… worldview—defined as an intellectual, emotional, and spiritual decision-making filter”
Biblical Worldview:For the purposes of the research, a biblical worldview was defined as believing that absolute moral truths exist; that such truth is defined by the Bible; and firm belief in six specific religious views. Those views were that Jesus Christ lived a sinless life; God is the all-powerful and all-knowing Creator of the universe and He stills rules it today; salvation is a gift from God and cannot be earned; Satan is real; a Christian has a responsibility to share their faith in Christ with other people; and the Bible is accurate in all of its teachings. (1)
2022_05_27 II God’s Insiders.An alignment of a Biblical Worldview with Quality Management and Citizenship. “In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.” (Genesis 1) And, there was variation.
Similar to the Consitution, the Bible is seen by many to be a “living document” that should be interpreted to fit with the times as opposed to relying on the original intent or meaning of the author (s). In a biblical context, heresy is defined as a “self-chosen doctrine not emanating from God” ( 2 Peter 2:1 ).
A new poll shock has revealed that most Christian pastors believe what they want to believe, a “blending of ideas and applications from a variety of holistic worldviews into a unique but inconsistent combination that represents their personal preferences.”
In fact, just slightly more than a third (37%) have a biblical worldview and the majority – 62% – possess a hybrid worldview known as Syncretism.”
“One group within the general public that is more likely to possess a biblical worldview than pastors are SAGE Cons (Spiritually Active Governance Engaged Conservative Christians). The American Worldview Inventory 2021 showed that 46% of SAGE Cons have a biblical worldview, a full nine percentage points higher than the incidence among pastors.” Are You a Sage Con_Courage for Life, May 2022.
A new nationwide survey of Christian pastors in the United States has revealed that nearly two-thirds of them (62 percent) do not have a biblical worldview. That may sound shocking to you, but this is exactly what the Bible said we would see in the last days.
The pastors who don’t have a biblical worldview are likely to embrace competing worldviews, including Secular Humanism, Marxism, or Syncretism. Barna describes the mix-and-match Syncretism perspective as “the blending of ideas and applications from a variety of holistic worldviews into a unique but inconsistent combination that represents their personal preferences.” … More than six out of every 10 American pastors fall into this category of Syncretism.
Only four in 10 pastors have a biblical worldview about the truth of God’s Word and what it teaches about how we live our lives.
WASHINGTON, D.C. — The vast majority of U.S. adults believe in God, but the 81% who do so is down six percentage points from 2017 and is the lowest in Gallup’s trend. Between 1944 and 2011, more than 90% of Americans believed in God.
Gallup’s May 2-22 Values and Beliefs poll finds 17% of Americans saying they do not believe in God.
Gallup first asked this question in 1944, repeating it again in 1947 and twice each in the 1950s and 1960s. In those latter four surveys, a consistent 98% said they believed in God. When Gallup asked the question nearly five decades later, in 2011, 92% of Americans said they believed in God.
“The most valuable lesson humanity ought to have learned from philosophy is that it is impossible to make sense of truth without acknowledging God as the necessary starting point.”
There has been a steady decline in church attendance with each succeeding generation, and as a recent study from the Survey Center on American Life points out, poor parenting is one of the dominant factors.
The data described below are from telephone interviews with a nationwide random sample of 2,033 adults conducted during September through November 2003. The maximum margin of sampling error associated with the aggregate sample is ±2.2 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.
The research indicated that everyone has a worldview, but relatively few people have a biblical worldview – even among devoutly religious people. … The denominations that produced the highest proportions of adults with a biblical worldview were non-denominational Protestantchurches (13%), Pentecostal churches (10%) and Baptist churches (8%).
For the purposes of the research, a biblical worldview was defined as believing that absolute moral truths exist; that such truth is defined by the Bible; and firm belief in six specific religious views. Those views were that:
Jesus Christ lived a sinless life;
God is the all-powerful and all-knowing Creator of the universe and He still rules it today;
salvation is a gift from God and cannot be earned;
Satan is real;
a Christian has a responsibility to share their faith in Christ with other people; and
the Bible is accurate in all of its teachings.
Some Churches Are Helping People
The research found that one of the most effective methods of enabling people to develop a biblical worldview is by addressing seven critical questions that consistently lead to beliefs and behaviors that are in tune with biblical teaching. Outlining that process in a new book he has written as an outgrowth of the research, entitled Think Like Jesus, Barna also noted that many churches are already helping their congregants to implement such a way of addressing daily challenges and opportunities….
Community Calendar. The Brown County Democrat publishes announcements, events, and training opportunities for Churches and other non-profits in the “Community Calendar” section of the paper and on their website.
Biblical Worldview – Audio – Jun 5, 2022 Sunday Sermon – Pastor Ethan Scott dives into Galatians 1:1-5. May God bless you and your family as we grow together in the Word!
Topics include:
How does persecution happen? Through false teachings – idolatry, dangerous
Church – lack of unity and integrity in the body of Christ
Bombardment of manmade ideas that puts the focus on man, not God.
Cultural Christianity
Barna Survey – Biblical Worldview Survey
As a percent of church attendance, the smallest its ever been
Choose to worship at the church that is closest to the Bible
Paul’s message against false teachings: False teachings produce idolatry
Paul’s authority was challenged to undermine the Gospel
The New Covenant
The True Gospel glorifies God, man’s religion seeks man’s glory
How do these truths impact us and how we live?
Repent, accept and believe in Christ – (leads to eternal life)
Claim discipleship in Christ, share the Word
Focusing on good works that bring attention to man and not God, produces division in the church and is idolatry
As a Church, we must teach the Gospel in every area of our gathering and in our community – scare with truth as opposed to appeasing with lies.
To ensure we do not proclaim false teachings, we must abide in God’s Word.
Be teachable – Only God has it all figured out.
Be gracious and peaceful with your brothers and sisters in Christ.
The denominations that produced the highest proportions of adults with a biblical worldview were non-denominational Protestant churches (13%), Pentecostal churches (10%) and Baptist churches (8%).
Seven Life-Changing Questions (George Barna, Thinking Like Jesus, pg. 14)
o. Court House Projects. Commissioners voted to move forward on contracting for two additions to the courthouse. One on the north side to allow for a Sally Port, a holding cell, and a separate entrance. Currently, prisoners have to use the same entrance as the public and the only holding area in a stairwell. An addition to the East Side is also planned to allow more space for security screening. Currently, the security officer and metal detector are located in the narrow hallway. The total cost is estimated at around $687, 500. The judge has previously obtained grants to make needed renovations and comply with ADA requirements. The Sally Port is a “need” as is the space for security screening. Funding was identified with the majority coming from the funds set aside to purchase the CRC building from the school that was to be used by the Prosecutor’s Office. No current plans to replace the Prosecutor’s Office. In 2019, the county spent 16K on a needs study that failed to make the case that the county needed a new “Justice Center” at a cost of around $10 million. This would have provided space that would have included the Court Staff and Prosecutor’s Office.
o. Traffic Light – at the Park Entrance – North Gate. After a recent accident, the issue of requesting a traffic light from the State has been renewed. I suggested the county post the traffic study that was conducted by the State. The analysis in the past has not justified a Light. Given the volume and type of traffic (more RVs for example), a light would slow traffic, cause back-ups and delay travel times.
o. Road Projects. Bids were received from four contractors for the currently proposed projects. Total bid costs ranged from $3,118,771 to $4,015,995. The winning vendor and specific projects will be announced at the next commissioner meeting.
o. New Coroners Office. The current cost is estimated at 175K and work may begin in late summer.
The two most important issues at the root of every debate about the application of morality to civil government and culture are the standards we use to judge good and evil and the entity that decides those standards. How we resolve both will determine the future of our nation. – Squires
As for “Christian nationalism,” WE RECOGNIZE that for some, this simply refers to a healthy form of Christian patriotism, of loving God and loving one’s country. In that sense, the term is benign.
WE ALSO RECOGNIZE that there is a dangerous and unhealthy form of “Christian nationalism,” one that speaks of a potential Christian uprising against the government or hints at the use of force to advance God’s kingdom.WE CATEGORICALLY AND UNEQUIVOCALLY DENY any affiliation with or connection to that form of Christian nationalism.
The Christian left takes a very different approach because it sees both the Bible and the Constitution as “living documents” that should evolve – both in meaning and application – as times change. For theological liberals, the designer is acknowledged, but individuals and the people who wield the most influence in a particular context define each aspect of creation and determine its purpose.
A recent Associated Press story claimed scholars characterize Christian nationalism by “a fusion of American and Christian values, symbols and identity” as well as the the belief that God “has destined America, like the biblical Israel, for a special role in history” and that the country “will receive divine blessing or judgment depending on its obedience.”
Those features sound ideologically neutral, … but most journalists and political liberals frame Christian nationalism as a white, conservative, patriarchal theonomic enterprise. They have created a religious avatar that, to quote one prominent historian of religion and society, is embodied by the contorted theology of Jesus and John Wayne.
But, think about it, who in the civilized West would oppose those who love God and country (i.e. Christian Nationalists) other than Luciferian globalists?
What Is Christian Nationalism? An explainer on how the belief differs from other forms of nationalism, patriotism, and Christianity. PAUL D. MILLER|
Christian nationalism is the belief that the American nation is defined by Christianity, and that the government should take active steps to keep it that way.
An Associated Press article on the influence of “Christian nationalism” on the 2022 primary elections has confirmed the fears of many voices on the left who are calling for action, lest the nation perish.
MSNBC host Joy Reid said via Twitter she was “glad to see the mainstream media beginning to make it plain, rather than trying to sugarcoat or both-sides this, because Christian nationalism poses a very real threat to American national security and social cohesion.”
But scholars generally define Christian nationalism as going beyond policy debates and championing a fusion of American and Christian values, symbols and identity. …Christian nationalism, they say, is often accompanied by a belief that God has destined America, like the biblical Israel, for a special role in history, and that it will receive divine blessing or judgment depending on its obedience.
Christian nationalism is emerging alongside and in some cases overlapping with other right-wing movements, such as the conspiratorial QAnon, white supremacy, and denialism over COVID-19 and the 2020 election. Christian prayers and symbols featured prominently in and around the U.S. Capitol during the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection there.
“In all manmade worldviews—which is everything but biblical Christianity—humans are ultimately attempting to construct and define human rights. If human rights originate from man, they can be added to, subtracted from, modified, revoked, or selectively applied by man. Old rights can be withdrawn to coerce and control people. New rights can be easily invented to push an agenda.”
The council voted 3-2 in favor of a second reading. A motion was then made to adopt the ordinance, passing with the same votes. Council President Nancy Crocker, Vice President Anna Hofstetter and councilmember Tyra Miller all voted in favor of the commission. Council members Jane Gore and David Rudd opposed both the second reading and the adoption.
Nashville Town Council Meeting Notes, July 21, 2022, 6:30 p.m. On the topic of the proposed Human Rights Commission Ordinance, the public was misled by the Town Council. As advertised, the council did not vote on a final version of the ordinance. The council voted on the first reading of a revised ordinance (Revised July 7, 2022). The public was not notified in advance or at the beginning of the meeting of the opportunity to comment on the revised ordinance. This version of the ordinance was shared at the July 7, 2022 council roundtable discussion (not an official meeting) but was not available on their website prior to that meeting. (Facebook Post at Brown County Matters)
At the beginning of the council meeting, President Crocker thanked everyone for their input on the ordinance. She stated that the council would be voting on a “reading of the final version of the ordinance but not a vote .” This was not an accurate statement. They did not vote on a “final version.” She went on to suggest that those attending just on the issue of the vote may not be interested in remaining.
On agenda item 6b, “Consider Ordinance 2022-03 Human Rights Commission Ordinance”, President Crocker stated that the original ordinance “was revised quite a bit and they were kind of going back to square one.” The town attorney advised that a “first reading” of the revised ordinance (revised July 7, 2022) was required.
Anna Hoffstetter made a motion to suspend the rules for a second reading so that the ordinance could be passed immediately. Her motion was not approved.
The council without any discussion on the comments, questions, and concerns provided by the public, voted to approve – the only no vote was from Dave Rudd.
Audio. Discussion on the first reading – revised ordinance at the 1:37 mark.
I suggest that the council send this draft back to a committee. The recommendation by the committee to create a commission was based on opinions and anecdotes. The public has provided sufficient information verbally and in writing to reinforce the need for a more thorough review of the facts, evidence, and analysis of alternatives.
Placing the issue on the Nov ballot is not an option.
July 21, 2022. Brown County Matters. Statement – President by the Town Council. My response and counter-responses. “FIY….. A sentence in the Democrat implied we are voting on the Human Rights Commission Ordinance tonight. That is not and never was my intention. The plan was to read the final revised ordinance and then vote next month. The online version of the paper has been corrected.”
My Response: Nancy Crocker You inferred at the last meeting that a vote could be taken if a motion was made and seconded and it was also mentioned that the idea could be placed on the ballot in Nov. Link below to the audio of the last meeting and background information on the proposed human rights commission ordinance to include the email addresses of town council members for those wanting to express an opinion.
Nancy Crocker That vote would have to be unanimous to vote on the ordinance.
July 21, 2022. Brown County Democrat – Facebook Post. NOTE: An earlier version of this story said the Nashville Town Council will vote on a second reading of the proposed Human Rights Commission. A second reading will be done, but no vote is set to be taken in regards to the commission, council president Nancy Crocker said today. The story has been updated for clarification.
July 21, 2022. Nashville Town Council Meeting – decision regarding the proposed Human Rights Commission. (Meeting Information).
Nancy Crocker, President (term 1/01/19 to 12/31/2022). Jane Gore, Vice-President (term 1/01/20 to 12/31/2023) Anna Hofstetter, Council Member (term 1/01/2019 to 12/31/2022) Tyra Miller, Council Member (term 1/01/20 to 12/31/2023) Dave Rudd, Council Member (term 1/01/2019 to 12/31/2022)
We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness— Declaration of Independence
In a Biblical worldview, man is imperfect, a sinner. Bigotry represents sinful behavior and sin is an inherent part of human nature. In alignment with the Constitution, civil rights laws have been created to identify unacceptable actions relative to discrimination, bias, prejudice, and bigotry. These laws are administered by the Federal government and the Indiana Civil Rights Commission (ICRC).
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has defined the distinction between Civil Rights protected by the Constitution and “Human Rights”. “The ACLU Human Rights Program (HRP) is dedicated to holding the United States accountable to international human rights laws and standards as well as the rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.”
A New Religion? Are “Human Rights” as “man” defines them independent of a biblical worldview, the new religion of the progressive left? Note that with ‘Rights” there are also “Wrongs.” Who decides what is right and wrong and by what moral authority?
Similar to the Constitution, the Bible is being considered by the progressive left as a “living document” that should be interpreted to reflect the current times.
“The Indiana Civil Rights Commission (ICRC) enforces the civil rights laws of the State of Indiana. We investigate complaints of discrimination and educate organizations, companies, landlords, associations, and individuals on their rights and responsibilities under Indiana Civil Rights Laws. If you feel you have been the victim of discrimination call 1-800-628-2909 or click here to file a complaint electronically.”
Brown County attracts over an estimated 1.5 million visitors a year. There were “6” race-related complaints in 2020 reported to the Visitors Center; the other complaints were due to accessibility issues. Three recent race-related incidents were covered in the Brown County Democrat – all three were resolved. The cause of the fourth incident was due to mental illness.
An essay titled “The Black Dilemma” was posted to the page on Saturday, April 24 and was no longer posted as of Sunday morning.
Oct 27, 2020. ‘We’re going to do better’: School administrators, parents, student respond to yearbook caption error, Suzannah Couch. Matt and Emily Roberts are the parents of the high school student who was identified as “BLACK GUY” instead of his name in a group photo in the school’s 2020 yearbook. The adviser and high school teacher the district stated was responsible for the error has resigned, the school district announced on Oct. 27.
Oct 11, 2017Hatchet attack suspect to be committed by Sara Clifford.The man accused of attacking a Chinese exchange student with a hatchet will be committed to a state hospital as soon as possible.
Is the ACLU’s program the model for Nashville’s Human Rights Commission? “The ACLU Human Rights Program (HRP) is dedicated to holding the United States accountable to international human rights laws and standards as well as the rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.”
When was the last time a Nashville resident was charged with a civil rights violation?
June 25 Follow-up. The Report – “Nashville Human Rights Advisory Committee Recommendation Document ” and an independent assessment are provided below. Reports from the State are also provided at the end of this post. Reports include the Formal Complaints Statewide and Region 9 Inquiries.
Brown County Matters – Facebook Post of the Article. Where is the link to the information (and data) provided in the research? Was this documented in a separate report to the council or just derived from anecdotes? Does the “report” include the data available from the state along with an explanation of the process for managing calls and complaints? Does the “report” include the operational definitions for the data?
Hren: We talked about the human rights ordinance that’s being worked on had one reading. What’s the next step?
Crocker: We were going to do a second reading at the last town council meeting. And in the last hour, a couple of groups that had questions and had initially said they were against it, met with some people, another council person and said, you know what, we’ve kind of reconsidered this. And we kind of would like you to just pause a minute for us to kind of get together and talk about it.
So we’re really, really hopeful that we can talk to them and help them understand how this is a good thing for our community. So we’ll do hopefully, a second reading at the next meeting. And again, this isn’t an emergency. So we’ll do a second reading in the June meeting and then we’ll have a vote on it then. That’s at least the tentative plan at this point.
At last night’s Town Council meeting, a member of DTOI overheard Nashville IN Town Council president Nancy Crocker state aloud: “The folks who are doing the freedom rallies [Don’t Tread On Indiana] approached us about putting this ordinance together.” She was talking about the human rights ordinance.
To be clear, Don’t Tread On Indiana has never contacted any Town Council official advocating in favor of the proposed human rights ordinance. This is because we stand staunchly against it, for reasons that will be elucidated in a future statement.
Why the Nashville Town Council president believes and stated aloud in public that DTOI ever encouraged the construction of this unnecessary and potentially counter-productive initiative is beyond our imagination. That’s a question best asked of Nancy Crocker.
The second reading of the draft was scheduled for May 19, 2022. It was postponed.
Context. The following article distinguishes the difference between tolerance, acceptance, and understanding. Tolerance is a virtue that is a basis for First Amendment protections. Just because you have tolerance for a situation does not mean you accept it. Dialogue can lead to understanding and a higher probability of positive change. Ref: Feb 25, 2014. Psychology Today, by Jefferson M Fish Ph.D. Tolerance, Acceptance, Understanding
Terms
WHEREAS the Town of Nashville recognizes the need for a Human Rights Commission to address issues of bias, discrimination, and prejudice in the community, which has been documented by comments and complaints in the community,by personal testimony, and by reported cases. NOTE: This paragraph was deleted in the current version (July 7, 2022) of the proposed ordinance. The so-called documentation is based on hearsay, anecdotes, and unsupported allegations.
Bigotry is another term linked to Bias, Discrimination, and Prejudice and could include just about anything. What human being is free from bigotry? What would be the criteria for accepting and processing complaints? Categories could include age, gender, appearance, race, culture, heritage, and politics.
Bias. a personal and sometimes unreasoned judgment
Discrimination. unfair treatment of a person or group on the basis of prejudice;
The definition of prejudice includes “harm caused by the adverse preconceptions of others.” Webster’s New World College Dictionary includes a description that: “
The definition of bigotry is prejudice and the state of being intolerant” and
a bigot is a person who is prejudiced, or intolerant of those who are different.”
Independent Assessment – Information provided by the state, BC Democrat, Visitors Center
The 8,581 calls to the Indiana Civil Rights Commission is statewide and includes the total number of times their phone rang (calls). The actual number of inquiries statewide was 2,082.
Region 9 consists of 16 counties. Of the 282, “calls”, there were 194 “inquiries.”
The ICRC does not track the region of formalized complaints. Once the complaint is formalized, they only track the protected classes.
The Visitors Center had 6 total complaints in 2020 regarding race…all others were due to accessibility issues. Complaints are given to the respective store owners.
“Personal testimony by shop owners, students and delivery drivers.” Anecdotal.
Rally. Total attendance was estimated at around 100. Does this include law enforcement and security personnel? Were any reports submitted by attendees?
Reports in the Democrat. There were two (2) associated with the school (blackface and yearbook) and one (1) with the local GOP. These were ALL resolved. No laws were broken and no charges were filed.
WHEREAS the Town of Nashville recognizes the need for a Human Rights Commission to address issues of bias, discrimination, and prejudice in the community, which has been documented by comments and complaints in the community, by personal testimony, and by reported cases and;
The Indiana Civil Rights Commission Annual Report of 2020 showed that 8,581 reports were made to the state office. Of those reports, 784 were drafted into complaints and of those complaints, 282 were from Region 9, which includes Brown County.
Should an individual face discrimination, they have the ability to inform the Human Rights Commission, who will then direct the individual to appropriate resources provided by the state.
The committee stated in their recommendation a record of “bias and discrimination” has been documented by the newspaper and by comments and complaints taken at the Visitors Center along with personal testimony by shop owners, students and delivery drivers. A need was also documented based on comments taken from more than 100 people who participated in the Nashville Solidarity Rally in 2020.
Potorti said in November that the town has few — if any — reliable or consistent ways to report or evaluate the quality and treatment of its citizens and visitors. … He said that precedence is already being established locally, like in the Brown County School Corporation which created a district Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) Committeeof staff members in 2019.
Nov 30, 2021. Human Rights Committee presents findings: Group calls for creation of official town commission to…Abigail Youmans. The Nashville Human Rights Committee has worked for the past nine months to evaluate the need for a town human rights commission. The committee presented its findings to the Nashville Town Council on Nov. 18 and stated that what they discovered showed there is a need for that type of commission locally.
Is there a published report available? Curious about the methodology used to collect the data. Too often, anecdotal information is incorrectly used to determine conclusions and identify “solutions.” Post of the article at Brown County Matters
Jan 27, 2021.Town council OKs human rights advisory committee. The Nashville Town Council is accepting applications through Feb. 17 to form a group of five people to study “the need, function, structure and scope of a Human Rights Commission.”
The council voted 4-1 last week to form a temporary citizens advisory committee on this topic, which will report to the town council after a three-month period with its findings.
Reports provided by the State
The Indiana Civil Rights Commission (ICRC) enforces the civil rights laws of the State of Indiana. We investigate complaints of discrimination and educate organizations, companies, landlords, associations, and individuals on their rights and responsibilities under Indiana Civil Rights Laws. If you feel you have been the victim of discrimination call 1-800-628-2909 or click here to file a complaint electronically.
Fecal contamination from humans and animals is widespread in streams E. coli is an indicator of fecal contamination. While E. coli itself is generally not harmful, many other harmful bacteria and viruses are present in fecal matter. E. coli levels in all the 2020 Lake Monroe samples were well below the state standard of 235 CFU/100 ml (CFU = colony forming units of bacteria).
However, historical beach sampling data shows E. coli exceedances in 2015 and 2016 ranging from 632 CFU/100 ml to >2,400 CFU/100 ml. There were multiple E. coli exceedances in streams throughout the watershed. The South Fork sub-watershed appears to be the largest contributor of E. coli. Source analysis indicates that both human and animal fecal contamination are present. This widespread contamination renders streams unsafe for swimming or wading and contributes to nutrient overloading in the lake. Potential sources include livestock manure, pet waste, wildlife manure, and septic system leachate.
Septic system maintenance and repair can reduce nutrient and bacteria input Poorly functioning septic systems are another potential source of nutrients and bacteria. There are over 9,000 septic systems in the watershed. Many homeowners are unaware that their septic tank should be pumped and inspected about every 3 years. While a properly functioning septic system can be highly effective, another strategy to reduce potential leakage is to expand existing sewer lines and decrease the number of active septic systems.
June 9, 2022. Lake Monroe forums happening
The Friends of Lake Monroe and the Leagues of Women Voters of Bloomington-Monroe County and Brown County will host several community forums to discuss the newly published Lake Monroe Watershed Management Plan.
The Lake Monroe Watershed Management Plan, developed by the Friends of Lake Monroe, is the product of a two-year project gathering and analyzing data about the lake and its watershed. The report summarizes the available data, identifies the top threats to water quality and outlines an action plan to reduce non-point source pollution. Public input is now needed to help prioritize project implementation and to mobilize the community to take action.
The first forum will be held on May 24 from 6:45 to 8:30 p.m. at St. Thomas Lutheran Church, 3800 E. 3rd St. in Bloomington.
The second forum will be held on June 9 from 6:45 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. at the Brown County Public Library, 205 Locust Lane.
The final forum will be held virtually on June 15 during the same time frame. The Zoom link will be sent in advance.
Those interested should visit docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfxdfwbSZF9P2SjskNft4U3l9iEfhk7_uan25j5Dl6M1ioFUg/viewform to register. For questions, contact Lake Monroe Watershed Coordinator Maggie Sullivan at watershed@friendsoflakemonroe.org or 812-558-0217.
The full Lake Monroe Watershed Management Plan and a shorter executive summary are available online at friendsoflakemonroe.org/watershed-plan/.
Updated: July 20, 2022 
Independent Voters of Brown County IN 